☐ |
Prelimin ary Proxy Statem ent | |||
☐ |
Confidential, for Use of the Commission Only (as permitted by Rule 14a-6(e)(2)) | |||
☒ |
Definitive Proxy Statement | |||
☐ |
Definitive Additional Materials | |||
☐ |
Soliciting Material under Section 240.14a-2. | |||
(Name of Registrant as Specified In Its Charter) | ||||
(Name of Person(s) Filing Proxy Statement, if other than Registrant) | ||||
Payment of Filing Fee (Check the appropriate box): | ||||
☒ | No fee required. | |||
☐ | Fee computed on table in exhibit required by Item 25(b) per Exchange Act Rules 14a-6(i)(1) and 0-11 | |||
☐ | Fee paid previously with preliminary materials. |
Notice of 2023 Annual Meeting of Shareholders
May 5, 2023
9:00 a.m. Central Time
The Westin Chicago Lombard
70 Yorktown Center
Lombard, Illinois 60148
Dear Fellow Shareholder:
You are cordially invited to attend the Annual Meeting of Shareholders (the “Annual Meeting”) of Dover Corporation (“Dover” or the “Company”) at The Westin Chicago Lombard on May 5, 2023 at 9:00 a.m., Central Time, to be held for the following purposes:
1. | To elect nine directors. |
2. | To ratify the appointment of PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP (“PwC”) as our independent registered public accounting firm for 2023. |
3. | To approve, on an advisory basis, named executive officer (“NEO”) compensation. |
4. | To approve, on an advisory basis, the frequency of holding an advisory vote on executive compensation. |
5. | To consider a shareholder proposal regarding approval of certain termination payments, if properly presented. |
6. | To consider such other business as may properly come before the Annual Meeting, including any adjournments or postponements thereof. |
All holders of record at the close of business on March 8, 2023, are entitled to notice of and to vote at the Annual Meeting or any adjournments or postponements thereof. Whether or not you plan to attend the Annual Meeting, we urge you to vote your shares as soon as possible.
March 17, 2023
By authority of the Board of Directors,
Ivonne M. Cabrera
Secretary
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Notice of 2023 Annual Meeting of Shareholders | ||||
Proxy Statement Summary | 1 | |||
1 | ||||
1 | ||||
1 | ||||
2 | ||||
4 | ||||
5 | ||||
5 | ||||
6 | ||||
6 | ||||
8 | ||||
Proposal 1 — Election of Directors | 9 | |||
9 | ||||
10 | ||||
11 | ||||
20 | ||||
28 | ||||
30 | ||||
33 | ||||
Proposal 2 — Ratification of Appointment of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm |
34 | |||
35 | ||||
36 | ||||
Pre-Approval of Services Provided by Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm |
36 | |||
Compensation Discussion and Analysis | 37 | |||
37 | ||||
39 | ||||
Dover’s Alignment with Leading Compensation Governance Practices |
40 | |||
41 | ||||
42 | ||||
46 | ||||
53 | ||||
55 | ||||
56 | ||||
57 | ||||
57 | ||||
59 | ||||
60 | ||||
62 | ||||
62 | ||||
64 | ||||
65 | ||||
70 |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement i
TABLE OF CONTENTS
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement ii
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Annual Meeting Information
Date: | May 5, 2023 | |
Time: | 9:00 a.m., Central Time | |
Record Date: | March 8, 2023 | |
Location: | The Westin Chicago Lombard 70 Yorktown Center Lombard, Illinois 60148 | |
For additional information about our Annual Meeting, please see “General Information About the Annual Meeting.” We are first mailing this Notice of Annual Meeting and Proxy Statement beginning on or about March 17, 2023. |
Items of Business
There are five proposals to be voted on at the Annual Meeting:
ITEM
|
Proposal
|
Board Voting
|
Page Reference
|
|||||
ITEM 1
|
The election of nine nominees for director
|
FOR each director
|
|
9
|
| |||
ITEM 2
|
The ratification of the appointment of PwC as our independent registered public accounting firm for 2023
|
FOR
|
|
34
|
| |||
ITEM 3
|
An advisory resolution to approve NEO compensation
|
FOR
|
|
73
|
| |||
ITEM 4
|
An advisory resolution to approve the frequency of holding an advisory vote on executive compensation
|
ONE YEAR
|
|
74
|
| |||
ITEM 5
|
A shareholder proposal regarding approval of certain termination payments, if properly presented
|
AGAINST
|
|
75
|
|
How to Submit Your Proxy
Even if you plan to attend the Annual Meeting in person, please submit your proxy as soon as possible using one of the following methods:
• | Via internet by visiting www.proxyvote.com |
• | Via telephone by calling 1-800-690-6903 |
• | Via mail by marking, signing and dating your proxy card or voting instruction form (if you received proxy materials by mail) and returning it to the address listed therein |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 1
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Company Overview
Dover is a diversified global manufacturer and solutions provider delivering innovative equipment and components, consumable supplies, aftermarket parts, software and digital solutions, and support services through five operating segments: Engineered Products, Clean Energy & Fueling, Imaging & Identification, Pumps & Process Solutions, and Climate & Sustainability Technologies. We combine global scale, operational agility, world-class engineering capability, and customer intimacy to lead the markets we serve. Recognized for our entrepreneurial approach for over 65 years, our team of over 25,000 employees takes an ownership mindset, collaborating with customers to redefine what’s possible.
Management Philosophy
• | Our executive management team is committed to steady shareholder value creation through a combination of sustained long-term profitable growth, operational excellence, superior free cash flow generation, and productive capital re-deployment while adhering to a conservative financial policy. |
• | Our businesses seek to be leaders in a diverse set of growing markets where customers are loyal to trusted partners and suppliers, and value product performance and differentiation driven by superior engineering, manufacturing precision, total solution development, and excellent supply chain performance. |
• | Our companies are long-time leaders in their respective markets and are known for their innovation, engineering capability, and customer service excellence. |
• | Our sustainable business practices are focused on reducing environmental impact and developing products that help our customers meet their sustainability goals. |
• | Our operating structure of five business segments allows for differentiated acquisition focus consistent with our portfolio and capital allocation priorities which, coupled with value-creating functional expertise at our corporate center, presents opportunities to identify and capture operating synergies, such as global sourcing and supply chain integration, centralized shared services, and cross-pollination of manufacturing best practices. |
• | Our executive management team sets strategic direction, initiatives and goals, provides oversight of strategy execution and achievement of these goals for our business segments, and with oversight from our Board of Directors (our “Board”), makes capital allocation decisions, including organic investment initiatives, major capital projects, acquisitions, and the return of capital to our shareholders. |
• | Our operating culture fosters high ethical and performance standards, values accountability, rigor, trust, inclusion, respect, and open communications, and is designed to encourage individual growth and operational effectiveness. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 2
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Company Goals
We are committed to driving superior shareholder return through three key tenets of our corporate strategy.
|
We are committed to achieving organic sales growth above global gross domestic product growth (3% to 5% annually on average) over a long-term business cycle, absent prolonged adverse economic conditions, complemented by growth through strategic acquisitions. | |
|
We are focused on improving returns on capital, as well as segment and corporate earnings margins, by enhancing our operational capabilities and making investments across the organization in digital capabilities, automation, operations management, information technology, shared services, and talent. We also focus on continuous, effective cost management and productivity initiatives, including automation and digitally-supported manufacturing, supply chain optimization, e-commerce and digital go-to-market, restructuring activities, improved footprint utilization, strategic pricing and portfolio management. | |
|
We aim to generate strong and growing free cash flow and earnings per share (“EPS”) through strong earnings performance, productivity improvements, and active working capital management. |
We support achievement of these goals by aligning management compensation with strategic and financial objectives, actively managing our portfolio to increase enterprise scale, improving business mix over time, pursuing acquisitions that fit the characteristics of an ideal Dover business, and investing in talent development programs.
2022 Financial Results
In 2022, we continued our long track record of delivering value to our shareholders, despite an operational environment that continues to present challenges due to ongoing input shortages, inflationary cost pressure and foreign currency translation headwinds.
US GAAP |
FY2022 | FY2021 | Δ | |||||||||
Revenue ($M) |
8,508 | 7,907 | 8% | |||||||||
Net earnings ($M) |
1,065 | 1,124 | (5)% | |||||||||
Diluted EPS ($) |
7.42 | 7.74 | (4)% | |||||||||
Non-GAAP(1) |
||||||||||||
Organic revenue change |
9% | |||||||||||
Adjusted net earnings ($M)(2) |
1,213 | 1,109 | 9% | |||||||||
Adjusted diluted EPS ($) |
8.45 | 7.63 | 11% |
(1) Definitions and reconciliations of non-GAAP measures are included at the end of this proxy statement.
(2) Full year 2022 and 2021 adjusted net earnings exclude after tax purchase accounting expenses of $139.4 million and $107.2 million, respectively, and restructuring and other costs of $30.8 million and $31.1 million, respectively. Full year 2022 also excludes a $22.6 million reduction to income taxes previously recorded related to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, and full year 2021 excludes a $135.5 million gain on the sale of Unified Brands and a $18.0 million gain related to the sale of our Race Winning Brands equity method investment.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 3
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
2022 Performance Overview
Capital Return Program |
• We continued our history of providing regular capital returns to shareholders by increasing our quarterly dividend, marking our 67th consecutive year of dividend increases.
• We made $585 million of share repurchases in 2022, including completing a $500 million accelerated share repurchase program.
| |||
Portfolio & Strategic Actions |
• We made a total of five bolt-on acquisitions totaling $325 million, net of cash acquired and including contingent consideration, which complement and expand upon our existing operations.
| |||
Strong Operational Execution and Profitability |
• Increased 2022 revenue and delivered strong margin improvement in the fourth quarter despite ongoing input shortages, inflationary cost pressure and foreign currency translation.
• We continued to execute on our broad-based multi-year efficiency and margin expansion program, designed to reduce our selling, general and administrative cost base and rationalize our manufacturing and supply chain footprint across the portfolio.
• Continuing to build upon our four enterprise capabilities in support of margin expansion initiatives.
- We are continuing to (1) leverage our Digital Labs team to improve our internal and market-facing digital capabilities, (2) improve utilization and optimization of our manufacturing footprint through centralized resources and investment, (3) further centralize shared services under Dover Business Services, and (4) invest in our India Innovation Center shared services with a focus on engineering capabilities.
• Synergy capture from recent acquisitions presents additional margin upside.
| |||
Organic Investment |
• We made $221.0 million in capital expenditures in 2022, representing 2.6% of revenue, in line with our plan to support growth capacity, digitization, innovation, and productivity.
| |||
ESG Initiative |
• Completed our initial three-year plan to expand the scope and robustness of our environmental, social, and governance (“ESG”) practices and disclosures.
- Our ESG website contains disclosure on eighteen topics identified as areas of focus during the three-year plan.
- We continue to report our company-wide greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions and progress against our science-based targets to reduce our GHG emissions, including an absolute reduction of scope 1 and scope 2 market-based GHG emissions of 30 percent by 2030 (from a 2019 baseline year), and an absolute reduction of scope 3 GHG emissions of 15 percent by 2030 (from a 2019 baseline year).
- We continue to report our progress against our goal of reducing Total Recordable Injury Rate (“TRIR”) by 40% by 2025 (from a 2019 baseline year).
- We completed our first annual global engagement survey, which yielded a 77% participation rate.
• Formalized our cross-functional Sustainability Steering Committee’s oversight responsibilities in a committee charter.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 4
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Governance Highlights
Our Board is committed to sound governance practices designed to promote the long-term interests of shareholders and strengthen Board and management accountability. Highlights include:
BOARD OF DIRECTORS |
GOVERNANCE HIGHLIGHTS |
| ||
✓ Independent Board leadership
✓ Diversity search policy for external director and Chief Executive Officer (“CEO”) searches conducted by third-party search firms
✓ All directors are independent, other than the CEO
✓ Annual election of directors
✓ Majority voting for directors and director resignation policy in uncontested elections
✓ Comprehensive annual individual evaluations of one-third of the directors
✓ Regular executive sessions of independent directors
✓ Robust succession planning
|
✓ 15% ownership threshold required to call a special meeting of shareholders
✓ Proxy access right at 3%/3 years/2 or 20% of Board/20 shareholder aggregation allowance
✓ Strong share retention guidelines for directors and executive officers
✓ Executive compensation driven by pay-for-performance philosophy
✓ Executive officers not permitted to hedge or pledge company shares
✓ In 2019, achieved removal of all remaining supermajority voting provisions in our charter |
Shareholder Engagement
We encourage feedback from shareholders and have a strong history of engaging with investors on a range of topics, including our executive compensation program, evolving trends and best practices. In 2022, we continued our focus on regularly engaging with shareholders. We reached out to holders of approximately 63% of our shares outstanding, and engaged with governance professionals and/or portfolio managers at investors holding approximately 39% of our shares outstanding. During these discussions, we discussed many topics, including Board oversight and composition, our commitment to diversity and inclusion, progress on our ESG program and disclosures, our executive compensation program, and our corporate governance practices. Investors continued to express broad support for our governance structures and executive compensation program, and shared their views on matters related to diversity and inclusion and our independent, well-qualified Board. Further, investors highlighted the importance of continuing our ongoing engagement with them in the future on long-term corporate strategy and ESG initiatives. For more detailed information regarding these discussions, please see “Shareholder Engagement and History of Board Responsiveness” on page 28.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 5
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Executive Compensation
Our compensation program for executive officers is designed to emphasize performance-based compensation in alignment with our business strategy.
2022 Executive Compensation
The following table summarizes pay mix for our CEO and other NEOs, which is highly performance-based.
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS
|
✓ Pay-for-performance philosophy — a substantial majority of NEO pay is performance-based and tied to Dover’s stock price performance
✓ Significant portion of long-term compensation is performance-based, with long-term incentives vesting over three years subject to rigorous three-year performance period
✓ Strong share ownership guidelines for NEOs
✓ Equity awards with anti-hedging and anti-pledging provisions
✓ Investors provided with clear disclosure regarding the individual strategic objectives and financial metrics in our Executive Officer Annual Incentive Plan (“AIP”)
✓ ESG oversight incorporated into our CEO’s individual strategic objectives in the AIP
✓ Robust clawback structure
|
Director Nominees
Our Governance and Nominating Committee maintains an active and engaged Board through a robust refreshment process, which focuses on ensuring our Board has a diverse skill set that benefits from both the industry- and company-specific knowledge of our longer-tenured directors, as well as the fresh perspectives brought by our newer directors.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 6
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Recent Changes to Board
Our Board recently welcomed Michael Manley to the Board of Directors in February 2023. As the Chief Executive Officer of AutoNation, Inc., the largest automotive retailer in the United States and the former Chief Executive Officer of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N.V., Mr. Manley brings valuable leadership experience to the Board. He has extensive knowledge of manufacturing operations and supply chains, multi-national business management, capital markets, and mergers and acquisitions.
Current directors Stephen K. Wagner and Mary Winston will not stand for election at this year’s Annual Meeting. Mr. Wagner and Ms. Winston will be retiring after having served on our Board since 2010 and 2005, respectively. Our Board expresses its deep appreciation to Mr. Wagner and Ms. Winston for their years of dedicated service to Dover, their effective independent leadership of Board committees over the years, and their camaraderie which will be missed from the Board’s deliberations.
NAME | OCCUPATION | INDEPENDENT | COMMITTEES MEMBERSHIPS* |
OTHER PUBLIC COMPANY BOARDS | ||||||
|
Deborah L. DeHaas Age: 63 Director Since: 2021 |
CEO of the Corporate Leadership Center; Former Vice Chairman of Deloitte and Managing Partner of the Center for Board Effectiveness | ✓ | A | 1 | |||||
|
H. John Gilbertson, Jr. Age: 66 Director Since: 2018 |
Retired Managing Director at Goldman Sachs | ✓ | A, F | 0 | |||||
|
Kristiane C. Graham Age: 65 Director Since: 1999 |
Private Investor | ✓ | C, G | 0 | |||||
|
Michael F. Johnston Chair of the Board Age: 75 Director Since: 2013 |
Retired CEO of Visteon Corporation | ✓ | C, G | 1 | |||||
|
Michael Manley Age: 59 Director Since: 2023 |
CEO of AutoNation, Inc. | ✓ | A, F | 2 | |||||
|
Eric A. Spiegel Age: 65 Director Since: 2017 |
Former President and CEO of Siemens USA; Special Advisor at Brighton Park Capital | ✓ | A, F (Chair) | 1 | |||||
|
Richard J. Tobin Age: 59 Director Since: 2016 |
President and CEO of Dover | No (CEO of Dover) |
— | 1 | |||||
|
Stephen M. Todd Age: 74 Director Since: 2010 |
Former Global Vice Chairman of Assurance Professional Practice of Ernst & Young Global Limited | ✓ | A (Chair) | 1 | |||||
|
Keith E. Wandell Age: 73 Director Since: 2015 |
Former President and CEO of Harley-Davidson, Inc. | ✓ | C (Chair), F | 1 |
*A = Audit Committee; C = Compensation Committee; G = Governance and Nominating Committee; F = Finance Committee
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 7
PROXY STATEMENT SUMMARY
Board Composition
Upon the retirements of Mr. Wagner and Ms. Winston, the Board will have the following composition:
Expanding the diversity of the Board will be a key objective as the Board considers future appointments. See page 9 for more information on our Board diversity policy and refreshment practices.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 8
Proposal 1 — Election of Directors
Criteria for Director Nominees
The Board seeks to recommend qualified director nominees who, in the opinion of the Board, demonstrate the highest personal and professional integrity as well as exceptional ability and judgment, who can serve as a sounding board for our CEO on planning and policy, and who will be most effective, together with the other nominees to the Board, in collectively serving the long-term interests of all our shareholders.
Key areas of expertise for director nominees, which are reflected in our current director nominees, include:
✓ Strategic M&A
|
Experience with international acquisitions, post-merger integration, and portfolio restructuring
| |||
✓ Global Operations & Management
|
Experience with cross-border transactions, global market entry and expansion, and implementation of operational efficiency
| |||
✓ Capital Markets
|
Experience with capital markets and complex financing transactions
| |||
✓ Strategy Development
|
Experience with diversified manufacturing in many of the markets and product areas relevant to Dover’s businesses
| |||
✓ Risk Management Expertise
|
Experience evaluating risk management policies and procedures
| |||
✓ Audit & Corporate Governance Matters
|
Experience with assurance and audit, regulation, and financial reporting
| |||
✓ Human Capital Management
|
Experience attracting, developing and retaining talent and building strong cultures
| |||
✓ Sustainability
|
Experience creating long-term value by embracing opportunities and managing risks deriving from ESG developments
| |||
✓ Executive Leadership Experience
|
Leadership experience as former CEOs and CFOs of global public companies
|
Diversity. Our Board believes that diverse perspectives enhance its decision-making and contribute to the success of Dover. In considering diversity in selecting director nominees, the Governance and Nominating Committee gives weight to the extent to which candidates would increase the effectiveness of the Board by broadening the mix of experience, knowledge, backgrounds, skills, ages, and tenures represented among its members. Our Board has adopted a policy, reflected in our Corporate Governance Guidelines, requiring that the initial list of potential director and external CEO candidates presented by third-party search firms include qualified candidates who reflect diverse backgrounds, including diversity of gender and race or ethnicity. Expanding the diversity of the Board will be a key objective as the Board considers future appointments.
Skills Aligned with Dover’s Strategy. The Governance and Nominating Committee also considers our current Board composition and the projected retirement date of current directors, as well as such other factors it may deem to be in the best interests of Dover and its shareholders, including a director nominee’s leadership and operating experience (particularly as a
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 9
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
CEO), financial and investment expertise, and strategic planning experience. We believe that our current director nominees possess the right mix of skills and backgrounds to enable us to achieve our strategic goals.
Independence & Depth of Experience. The Board prefers nominees to be independent but believes it is desirable to have our CEO on the Board as a representative of current management. Given the global reach and broad array of the types of businesses operated by Dover, the Governance and Nominating Committee highly values director nominees with multi-industry and multi-geographic experience.
Director Nomination Process
Whenever the Governance and Nominating Committee concludes that a new nominee to our Board is required or advisable, it will consider recommendations from directors, management, shareholders and, if it deems appropriate, consultants retained for that purpose. In such circumstances, it will evaluate individuals recommended by shareholders in the same manner as nominees recommended from other sources.
Shareholder Nominations for Director
Shareholders who wish to recommend an individual for nomination should send that person’s name and supporting information to the Governance and Nominating Committee, in care of the Corporate Secretary at our principal executive offices, 3005 Highland Parkway, Downers Grove, Illinois, 60515, or through our communications coordinator. Shareholders who wish to directly nominate an individual for election as a director, without going through the Governance and Nominating Committee, must comply with the procedures in our by-laws. Please see “General Information About the Annual Meeting” for nomination deadlines.
Proxy Access Shareholder Right
Following extensive engagement with our shareholders, our Board determined to adopt proxy access in February 2016, permitting a shareholder or group of up to 20 shareholders holding 3% of our outstanding shares of common stock for at least three years to nominate a number of directors constituting the greater of two directors or 20% of the number of directors on our Board, as set forth in detail in our by-laws.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 10
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
2023 Director Nominees
There are nine nominees for election to our Board at this Annual Meeting, each to serve until the next annual meeting of shareholders or his or her earlier removal, resignation or retirement. All nominees currently serve on our Board and are being proposed for re-election by our Board.
If any nominee for election becomes unavailable or unwilling to serve as a director before the Annual Meeting, an event which we do not anticipate, the persons named as proxies will vote for a substitute nominee or nominees as may be designated by our Board, or the Board may reduce the number of directors. Directors will be elected by a majority of the votes cast in connection with their election.
|
Deborah L. DeHaas
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2021 Age: 63
Committees: Audit
| ||||
|
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Significant leadership, financial and corporate governance expertise garnered from her nearly 40 years of experience at major audit, assurance and consulting firms |
• | Certified public accountant (“CPA”) and has extensive experience with financial, accounting, internal controls, and enterprise risk management |
• | Has deep expertise on governance, both as a topic and discipline, developed during her career at Deloitte |
• | As a former member of the Value Reporting Foundation Board (formerly the SASB Foundation Board), contributes valuable and well-informed insights on a variety of ESG matters |
• | Brings relevant public company board service, serving on the board of CF Industries Holdings, Inc. |
• | Brings experience and perspective on matters regarding human capital and culture, including diversity and inclusion |
• | Holds a bachelor’s degree in management science and accounting from Duke University |
• | Included in the National Association of Corporate Directors (“NACD”) Directorship 100 from 2015-2020, recognizing influential leaders in corporate governance and is also an NACD Board Leadership Fellow |
Business Experience: |
• | CEO of the Corporate Leadership Center, a non-profit leadership development forum |
• | Former Vice Chairman and National Managing Partner of the Center for Board Effectiveness at Deloitte |
• | Former member of the U.S. Executive Committee |
• | Former Vice Chairman and Chief Inclusion Officer |
• | Former member of the U.S. Board of Directors |
• | Former Vice Chairman and Central Region Managing Partner |
• | Former Vice Chairman and Midwest Regional Managing Partner |
• | Former Regional Managing Partner, Strategic Clients |
• | Former positions of increasing responsibility at Arthur Andersen, an audit, financial advisory, tax and consulting firm, most recently as Managing Partner & Business Advisory Assurance, Central Region |
Other Board Experience: |
• | CF Industries Holdings, Inc. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 11
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
H. John Gilbertson, Jr.
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2018 Age: 66
Committees: Audit, Finance
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Extensive experience in corporate finance, capital markets, and mergers and acquisitions |
• | Served as a strategic and financial advisor to his clients, forming deep relationships with companies in a range of industries |
• | Has nearly four decades of experience in the professional and financial services industry |
• | Deep expertise in financial management, coupled with his analytical and collaborative mindset, allows him to make invaluable contributions to our Board |
• | Strong background in senior leadership development, succession planning, and organizational culture development |
• | Brings to the Board considerable expertise in financial risk oversight and capital allocation |
• | Bachelor’s degree in political economy from Dartmouth College and an MBA from Harvard University |
Business Experience: |
• | Retired Managing Director at Goldman Sachs |
• | Served as Advisory Director and Partner-in-Charge, Midwest Region Investment Banking Services |
• | Served as Managing Director at Travelers Group Inc. |
• | Former Associate, Mergers and Acquisitions at Morgan Stanley |
• | Former Consultant, Corporate Strategy at Bain & Company |
• | Former Assistant Treasurer, Corporate Banking at Chase Manhattan Bank |
• | Former News Reporter at The Providence Journal Company |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director and Chair of Audit Committee of Meijer, Inc. (“Meijer”) |
• | Former Director of AAR Corp. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 12
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Kristiane C. Graham
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 1999 Age: 65
Committees: Compensation, Governance and Nominating
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Experience as a private investor with substantial holdings of Dover stock and her shared interests in Dover, including interests through charitable organizations of which she is a director, makes her a good surrogate for our individual and retail investors |
• | Experience with a commercial bank, primarily as a loan officer; founded and operated an advisory company and a publication regarding international thoroughbred racing and now co-manages her family’s investments |
• | Actively works with and has served on the boards of various organizations to support the objectives of local communities, affordable housing, education, and health |
• | Serves on the Board of Directors for the Walter N. Ridley Scholarship Fund at the University of Virginia |
• | Serves on the Board of Directors of Habitat for Humanity International |
• | Serves on the Board of Trustees of the Virginia Museum of Fine Arts Foundation |
• | Serves as an Emeritus Trustee of the College Foundation of the University of Virginia and has previously served on the Advisory Board of the University of Virginia School of Nursing |
• | Brings valuable insights on the development of our policies and strategies relating to talent, leadership, and culture, with a focus on diversity and inclusion |
• | Devoted substantial time to monitoring the development of Dover operating company leaders, enabling her to provide the Board valuable insights regarding management succession |
• | As a member of one of the founding families of Dover, Ms. Graham also brings to the Board a sense of Dover’s historical values, culture and strategic vision which the Board believes is beneficial as it considers various strategic planning alternatives for shaping Dover’s future |
Business Experience: |
• | Private Investor |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 13
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Michael F. Johnston
| |||
| ||||
Independent Board Chair; Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2013 Age: 75
Committees: Compensation, Governance and Nominating
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Brings industry insight, financial expertise and leadership experience garnered from his 17 years on the boards of global companies |
• | Served as CEO of an $18 billion global manufacturer |
• | Mr. Johnston also brings valuable corporate governance perspectives from his prior board service, including as a lead Director and Chair of other major public companies |
• | Brings deep operations experience, which has helped him gain knowledge and a deep understanding in manufacturing, design, innovation, engineering, accounting and finance and capital structure |
• | Brings nearly two decades of experience in building businesses in emerging economies |
• | Bachelor’s degree in industrial management from the University of Massachusetts and an MBA from Michigan State University |
Business Experience: |
• | Former CEO and President of Visteon Corporation (“Visteon”) |
• | Former Chief Operating Officer of Visteon |
• | Former President of North America/Asia Pacific, Automotive Systems Group, of Johnson Controls, Inc. (“Johnson Controls”) |
• | Former President of Americas Automotive Group of Johnson Controls |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director of Armstrong Flooring, Inc. |
• | Former Chairman and Director of Visteon |
• | Former Director of Armstrong World Industries, Flowserve Corporation, and Whirlpool Corporation |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 14
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Michael Manley
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2023 Age: 59
Committees: Audit, Finance
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Currently the Chief Executive Officer of AutoNation, Inc., the largest automotive retailer in the United States |
• | Successfully managed a wide array of business models over his career |
• | Extensive knowledge of manufacturing operations and supply chains, multi-national business management, capital markets, and mergers and acquisitions |
• | MBA from Ashridge Management College and a Bachelor of Science in engineering from Southbank University |
Business Experience: |
• | Chief Executive Officer AutoNation, Inc. |
• | Former head of Americas and member of the Group Executive Council for Stellantis N.V. |
• | Former Chief Executive Officer of Fiat Chrysler Automobiles N.V. (“FCA”), a predecessor to Stellantis N.V. |
• | Former Executive Vice President - International Sales & Marketing, Business Development and Global Product Planning Operations |
• | Former Chief Executive Officer of Jeep |
• | Former Chief Executive Officer of Ram |
• | Former Chief Operating Officer for the Asia Pacific region |
• | Former FCA Global Executive Council member |
Other Board Experience: |
• | AutoNation |
• | Rolls-Royce Holdings plc (until 2023 annual meeting) |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 15
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Eric A. Spiegel
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2017 Age: 65
Committees: Audit, Finance (Chair)
|
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Experienced business leader with diversified, global experience who brings deep and valuable expertise in strategy development, corporate restructuring, portfolio management and M&A to our Board |
• | 40+ years of experience working with large, global companies in the energy and industrial markets, mostly recently as President & CEO of Siemens USA |
• | At Siemens, he led strategic reviews across a portfolio of ~45 businesses in the company’s largest market with over $22 billion in revenue, 50,000 employees and over 60 manufacturing facilities |
• | Participated in the acquisition, divestiture, joint venture and carve-out of over 30 business units and segments |
• | Executed Siemens’ “Vision 2020” initiative to optimize growth and margins in the U.S., across all sectors |
• | Prior to Siemens, Mr. Spiegel was a global consultant at Booz Allen Hamilton focused on complex organizations in the energy, power, chemical, water, industrial and automotive fields |
• | At Booz, he worked with major energy clients globally on projects around corporate strategy, M&A, major capital projects, cost restructuring, margin enhancement and supply chain re-design and was also closely involved with the government sector |
• | An expert on the global energy industry, Mr. Spiegel co-authored the book Energy Shift: Game-changing Options for Fueling the Future |
• | Holds a bachelor’s degree in economics from Harvard University and an MBA from the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth College |
Business Experience: |
• | Special Advisor at Brighton Park Capital, a private equity firm, where he supports the firm’s sector investment teams and portfolio companies by providing strategic counsel on industry trends and growth strategies |
• | Former President and CEO of Siemens USA |
• | Former Managing Partner, Global Energy, Chemicals, and Power, and Managing Partner, Washington, D.C. office, and other roles at Booz & Company, Inc. (now known as Strategy&) and Booz Allen Hamilton, Inc., global consulting firms |
• | Former Associate, Energy and Industrials Practice, at Temple, Barker & Sloane, Inc. (now known as Oliver Wyman) |
• | Former Marketing and Strategy Manager at Brown Boveri & Cie (now known as ABB), a Swiss group of electrical engineering companies |
• | In connection with his position at Brighton Park Capital, Mr. Spiegel serves as Chair of Relatient, Inc. |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director and Audit Committee Chair of Liberty Mutual Holding Company, Inc. |
• | Director and Audit Committee Chair of Project Energy Reimagined Acquisition Corp. |
• | Director of TeamBuilder LLC |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 16
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Richard J. Tobin
| |||
| ||||
Chief Executive Officer Director since: 2016 Age: 59
Committees: None
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Mr. Tobin is Dover’s current CEO. The Board believes it is desirable to have one active management representative on the Board to facilitate its access to timely and relevant information and its oversight of management’s long-term strategy, planning, and performance |
• | Has a broad range of industry and functional experiences acquired through regional and global leadership positions |
• | Former CEO of CNH Industrial, a complex international industrial company, where he led efforts to increase efficiencies, innovate through new technologies, expand geographically, and maximize the company’s portfolio of businesses |
• | Gained extensive experience in international finance, operations, management, and information technology in his prior roles |
• | Developed deep expertise with global capital markets through his international finance leadership roles |
• | Prior to beginning his business career, Mr. Tobin was an officer in the United States Army |
• | Member of the Board of Trustees of the John G. Shedd Aquarium in Chicago |
• | Formerly served on the U.S. Chamber of Commerce Board of Directors, and is a former member of the Business Roundtable |
• | Holds a bachelor of arts from Norwich University and an MBA from Drexel University |
Business Experience: |
• | President and CEO of Dover |
• | Former CEO of CNH Industrial NV (“CNH Industrial”) |
• | Former Group Chief Operating Officer of Fiat Industrial S.p.A |
• | Former President and CEO of CNH Global NV |
• | Former CFO of CNH Global NV |
• | Former Chief Finance Officer & Head of Information Technology of SGS Group |
• | Former Chief Operating Officer for North America of SGS Group |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director of KeyCorp. |
• | Former director of CNH Industrial |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 17
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Stephen M. Todd
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2010 Age: 74
Committees: Audit (Chair)
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Extensive accounting and financial experience in both domestic and international business developed during a four decade career at Ernst & Young where he specialized in assurance and audit |
• | Brings unique insights into accounting and financial issues relevant to multinational companies like Dover |
• | Brings the perspective of an outside auditor to the Audit Committee |
• | Brings leadership and financial strategy experience as developer and director of Ernst & Young’s Global Capital Markets Centers, which provides accounting, regulatory, internal control and financial reporting services to multinational companies in connection with cross-border debt and equity securities transactions and acquisitions |
Business Experience: |
• | Former Global Vice Chair of Assurance Professional Practice of Ernst & Young Global Limited, London, UK; and prior thereto, various positions with Ernst & Young |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director and Audit Committee member of ChampionX Corporation (formerly known as Apergy Corporation) |
• | Former member of the Board of Trustees of PNC Funds |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 18
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
|
Keith E. Wandell
| |||
| ||||
Independent Director Nominee Director since: 2015 Age: 73
Committees: Compensation (Chair), Finance
| ||||
Skills and Qualifications: |
• | Mr. Wandell brings to the Board the valuable perspective of a strategic, experienced leader with a strong record focused on growth, profitability, international expansion and innovation. |
• | Has over 30 years of experience in diversified manufacturing businesses, most recently as the former Chairman and CEO of Harley-Davidson, Inc. (“Harley-Davidson”) where he led transformation efforts across the company’s product development, manufacturing and retail functions, focused on international expansion and implemented a restructuring plan |
• | Prior to joining Harley-Davidson, Mr. Wandell served as President and Chief Operating Officer of Johnson Controls, Inc. (“Johnson Controls”) and helped manage the company’s entry into the Chinese car-battery market as well as its subsequent joint venture with China’s largest battery manufacturer |
• | Gained valuable insights into the effective development of executive leadership capabilities and strong corporate cultures through his experience as a senior leader at various companies |
• | Served on the boards of four other public companies, including the two on which he currently serves |
• | Holds a bachelor’s degree in business administration from Ohio University and an MBA from the University of Dayton |
Business Experience: |
• | Former President and CEO of Harley-Davidson |
• | Former President and Chief Operating Officer of Johnson Controls |
• | Former Executive Vice President of Johnson Controls |
• | Former Corporate Vice President of Johnson Controls |
• | Former President of the Automotive Experience business of Johnson Controls |
• | Former President of the Power Solutions business of Johnson Controls |
Other Board Experience: |
• | Director of Dana Incorporated |
• | Former Director of Constellation Brands, Inc. and Clarcor, Inc. |
• | Former Chairman of Harley-Davidson |
THE BOARD RECOMMENDS A VOTE “FOR” THE ELECTION OF EACH
OF THE NOMINEES NAMED ABOVE.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 19
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Board Oversight and Governance Practices
Our Board is responsible for, and committed to, overseeing our long-term strategic development as well as managing the principal and most significant risks that we face. In carrying out this duty, our Board advises senior management to help drive long-term value creation for our shareholders. The Board delegates specific areas of responsibility to relevant Board committees, as detailed below under the heading “Overview of Committee Responsibilities”, who report on their deliberations to the Board. The following summarizes our Board’s key areas of oversight responsibility.
Board Oversight
KEY AREAS OF BOARD OVERSIGHT | ||
Long-Term Business Strategy |
• One of the primary responsibilities of our Board is the oversight of management’s long-term strategy and planning. Accordingly, our Board maintains a deep level of engagement with management in setting and overseeing Dover’s long-term business strategy.
| |
Capital Allocation |
• Our Board is focused on the efficient allocation of capital to drive growth and provide returns to our shareholders. Our capital allocation priorities are organic investments, strategic acquisitions, and the return of capital to our shareholders.
• We consistently return cash to shareholders by paying dividends, which have increased annually over each of the last 67 years.
• We also undertake opportunistic share repurchases as part of our capital allocation strategy, completing $585 million of share repurchases in 2022 including a $500 million ASR program.
• We made $221 million in capital expenditures in 2022, representing 2.6% of revenue, and $171.5 million in capital expenditures in 2021, representing 2.2% of revenue, in line with our priority of organic reinvestment to grow and strengthen our existing businesses.
• We employ a prudent financial policy to support our capital allocation strategy, which includes maintaining an investment grade credit rating.
| |
Portfolio Management |
• Businesses in our portfolio are continually evaluated for strategic fit.
• We seek to deploy capital in acquisitions in attractive growth areas across our five segments. We focus primarily on bolt-on acquisitions, applying strict selection criteria of market attractiveness (including growth, market landscape, and performance-based competition), business fit (including sustained leading position, revenue visibility, and favorable customer value-add versus switching cost or risk) and financial return profile (accretive growth and margins and double-digit return on invested capital).
• We have sold or divested some of our businesses based on changes in specific market outlook, structural changes in financial performance, value-creation potential, or for other strategic considerations, which included an effort to reduce our exposure to cyclical markets or focus on our higher margin growth spaces.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 20
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
KEY AREAS OF BOARD OVERSIGHT | ||
Risk |
• Our Board has established a comprehensive enterprise risk management process to identify and manage risks, and periodically reviews the processes established by management to identify and manage risks and communicates with management about these processes.
• We have established a risk assessment team consisting of senior executives, which annually, with the assistance of a consultant, oversees a risk assessment made at the corporate center, segment and operating company levels and, with that information in mind, performs an assessment of the overall risks our company may face and reports to the Board on that assessment. Each quarter, this team reassesses the risks, the severity of these risks, and the status of efforts to mitigate them.
| |
ESG |
• The full Board has oversight of ESG matters and is regularly briefed on strategic planning, risks, and opportunities related to ESG by senior management, including our CEO.
• Our Compensation Committee has integrated ESG oversight responsibility into our CEO’s individual strategic objectives within the AIP.
| |
Culture & Human Capital Management |
• Our entrepreneurial culture depends upon an inclusive approach that values employees’ diversity and contributions.
• We foster an operating culture with high ethical standards that values accountability, rigor, trust, inclusion, respect, and open communication and is designed to encourage individual growth and operational effectiveness. We continue to make significant investments in talent development, including in the areas of digital applications and operational management, and recognize that the growth and development of our employees is essential for our continued success.
• As part of our commitment to strong corporate governance practices, we maintain an active and robust ethics program. Our Code of Conduct applies to all employees and directors of Dover and its subsidiaries. We enforce our Code of Conduct fairly and consistently, regardless of one’s position in Dover, and will not tolerate retaliation against those who report suspected misconduct in good faith.
| |
Succession Planning |
• Another of the Board’s primary responsibilities is overseeing a sound Board and management succession process. The Board has developed a comprehensive plan to address management succession — both over the long term and for emergency purposes. The framework for the long-term plan includes thoughtful, deliberate monitoring of management beyond our top executives to ensure Dover continues to build a deep internal bench of talent.
• Our Board is also focused on its own succession plan, which drives not only our director selection efforts, but also how we approach Board and committee leadership structure and membership, with a focus on critical board skills, diversity, and independence. The recent appointment of Michael Manley demonstrates our commitment to active Board refreshment.
| |
Cybersecurity |
• The full Board is briefed on enterprise-wide cybersecurity risk management and the overall cybersecurity risk environment, and oversees major tasks related to cybersecurity risk management, periodically reviews our response capabilities, and meets with the Chief Information Security Officer on at least an annual basis.
• Dover employs the National Institute of Standards & Technology Framework for Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity (The NIST Framework). This voluntary guidance developed with much private sector input provides a framework and a toolkit for organizations to manage cybersecurity risk.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 21
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Board Committees
Our Board has four standing committees — the Audit Committee, the Compensation Committee, the Governance and Nominating Committee, and the Finance Committee. The table below sets forth a summary of our committee structure and membership information.
DIRECTOR |
Audit Committee |
Compensation Committee |
Governance and Nominating |
Finance Committee | ||||
DEBORAH L. DEHAAS |
✓ | |||||||
H. JOHN GILBERTSON, JR. |
✓ |
✓ | ||||||
KRISTIANE C. GRAHAM |
✓ |
✓ |
||||||
MICHAEL F. JOHNSTON |
✓ | ✓ | ||||||
MICHAEL MANLEY |
✓ | ✓ | ||||||
ERIC A. SPIEGEL |
✓ |
✓ (Chair) | ||||||
RICHARD J. TOBIN |
||||||||
STEPHEN M. TODD |
✓ (Chair) | |||||||
STEPHEN K. WAGNER* |
✓ | ✓ (Chair) | ||||||
KEITH E. WANDELL |
✓ (Chair) |
✓ | ||||||
MARY A. WINSTON* |
✓ |
✓ | ||||||
MEETINGS HELD IN 2022 |
8 | 5 |
4 | 7 |
* | Mr. Wagner and Ms. Winston will retire from the Board effective as of the Annual Meeting, at which time the size of our Board will be reduced to nine members. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 22
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Overview of Committee Responsibilities
Audit Committee | ||
Stephen M. Todd (Chair)
Deborah L. DeHaas H. John Gilbertson, Jr. Michael Manley Eric A. Spiegel Stephen K. Wagner |
Key Responsibilities
• Selecting and engaging our independent registered public accounting firm (“independent auditors”)
• Overseeing the work of our independent auditors and our internal audit function
• Approving in advance all services to be provided by, and all fees to be paid to, our independent auditors, who report directly to the committee
• Reviewing with management and the independent auditors the audit plan and results of the auditing engagement
• Reviewing with management and our independent auditors the quality and adequacy of our internal control over financial reporting
The Audit Committee holds regular quarterly meetings at which it meets separately with each of our independent registered public accounting firm, PwC, our internal audit function, financial management and our general counsel to assess certain matters including the status of the independent audit process, management’s assessment of the effectiveness of internal control over financial reporting and the operation and effectiveness of our compliance program. In addition, the Audit Committee, as a whole, reviews and meets to discuss the contents of each Form 10-Q and Form 10-K (including the financial statements) prior to its filing with the SEC.
Our Board has determined that all members of the Audit Committee qualify as “audit committee financial experts” as defined in the SEC rules.
The Audit Committee’s responsibilities and authority are described in greater detail in its written charter.
|
Compensation Committee | ||
Keith E. Wandell (Chair)
Kristiane C. Graham Michael F. Johnston Mary A. Winston |
Key Responsibilities
The Compensation Committee, together with our independent directors, approves compensation for the CEO of Dover. The functions of the Compensation Committee also include:
• Approving compensation for executive officers who report directly to the CEO (together with the CEO, “senior executive officers”)
• Granting awards and approving payouts under our 2012 Equity and Cash Incentive Plan (the “2012 LTIP”), our 2021 Omnibus Incentive Plan (the “2021 LTIP”) and our AIP
• Approving changes to our executive compensation plans
• Reviewing and recommending compensation for the Board
• Overseeing succession planning and management development programs
The Compensation Committee’s responsibilities and authority are described in greater detail in its written charter.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 23
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Governance and Nominating Committee | ||
Stephen K. Wagner (Chair)
Kristiane C. Graham Michael F. Johnston |
Key Responsibilities
• Developing and recommending corporate governance principles to our Board
• Annually reviewing the requisite skills and characteristics of board members as well as the size, composition, functioning and needs of our Board as a whole
• Considering and recommending to the Board nominees for election to, or for filling any vacancy on, our Board in accordance with our by-laws, our governance guidelines, and the committee’s charter
• Identifying and recommending to our Board any changes it believes desirable in the size and composition of our Board
• Recommending to our Board any changes it believes desirable in structure and membership of our Board’s committees
• Providing oversight of Dover’s practices on political contributions and lobbying expenses and reviewing annually Dover’s political contributions and lobbying expenses
The Governance and Nominating Committee’s responsibilities and authority are described in greater detail in its written charter.
|
Finance Committee | ||
Eric A. Spiegel (Chair)
H. John Gilbertson, Jr. Michael Manley Keith E. Wandell Mary A. Winston |
Key Responsibilities
• Reviewing and recommending for approval by the Board proposed changes to dividend policies, stock splits, and repurchase programs
• Reviewing our capital structure, liquidity, and financing plans
• Reviewing and approving the registration and issuance of debt or equity securities
• Subject to thresholds determined from time to time by the Board, reviewing and approving, or reviewing and recommending for Board approval, capital expenditures
• Subject to thresholds determined from time to time by the Board, reviewing and approving, or reviewing and recommending for Board approval, M&A transactions
• Oversight of treasury, insurance, and tax planning matters
The Finance Committee’s responsibilities and authority are described in greater detail in its written charter.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 24
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Corporate Governance
Our Board is committed to sound governance practices and regularly reviews and refines our profile to reflect evolving best practices and matters raised by our shareholders. The following summarizes key aspects of our governance framework.
GOVERNANCE HIGHLIGHTS | ||
Independent Board of Directors |
• All directors are independent, other than our CEO, and our Board has leadership that is independent from management, by way of an independent Chair. | |
Commitment to Diversity |
• Our Board has adopted a policy, reflected in our Corporate Governance Guidelines, requiring that the initial list of potential director and external CEO candidates presented by third-party search firms include qualified candidates who reflect diverse backgrounds, including diversity of gender and race or ethnicity. Expanding the diversity of the Board will be a key objective as the Board considers future appointments. | |
Special Shareholder Meetings |
• Our by-laws include a right of shareholders holding 15% or more of the voting power of our outstanding stock to call a special meeting of shareholders. | |
Elimination of |
• All of the supermajority voting provisions in our charter were eliminated in 2019. | |
Board Committee Refreshment |
• Our Board periodically reviews committee composition and chair positions, seeking the appropriate blend of continuity and fresh perspectives on committees. | |
Annual Majority Vote Director Elections & Mandatory Resignation Policy |
• All of our directors are elected annually by our shareholders.
• Our directors must receive a majority of the votes cast in uncontested elections to be elected.
• We have a director resignation policy that requires a director to tender an irrevocable resignation letter to the Board prior to being nominated, contingent on the director not receiving a majority of the votes cast in an uncontested election and the Board’s acceptance of the resignation. The Governance and Nominating Committee will recommend to the full Board whether to accept the resignation or whether to take other action. | |
Proxy Access |
• Our by-laws permit a shareholder or a group of up to 20 shareholders owning 3% or more of our outstanding common stock continuously for at least three years to nominate and include in our proxy materials director candidates constituting up to the greater of two individuals or 20% of the Board, provided that the shareholder(s) and the nominee(s) satisfy the requirements specified in our by-laws.
|
Board Leadership Structure
We believe that having an independent leader of the Board is important to the Board’s oversight role and decision-making involving corporate strategy, performance, succession, and other critical matters. Under our current Board leadership structure, our Board has leadership that is independent from management by way of an independent Chair. Our CEO is also a member of the Board as a management representative. We believe this is important to make information and insight directly available to the directors in their deliberations. In our view, this board leadership structure gives us an appropriate, well-functioning balance between non-management and management directors that combines experience, accountability and effective risk oversight.
Board, Committee and Individual Director Evaluations
Our Board and its committees conduct robust annual self-evaluations of their performance. In addition, our Board evaluates one-third of our directors on a rotating individual basis each year with the purpose of assisting each director to be a more effective member of the Board. New directors undergo the evaluation process in each of their first two years on the Board. Our directors believe the rotational nature of our evaluation process enables a more in-depth, comprehensive evaluation for each of our directors.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 25
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Directors’ Meetings and Attendance
During 2022, the Board met six times. Aside from Mr. Wagner, no director attended less than 75% of the board meetings and standing committee meetings on which he or she served in 2022. Average board attendance was 95% in 2022. Our independent directors meet at regularly scheduled executive sessions at least quarterly without management representatives or non-independent directors present. The Chair of the Board presides at these sessions. We expect our directors to attend the Annual Meeting. All directors then in office attended the 2022 Annual Meeting.
Our directors also regularly engage with management and outside subject matter experts outside of formal meetings. Examples include developing agendas and reviewing the content of materials in advance of meetings, calls, or in-person meetings with members of management to prepare for meetings, receiving periodic updates from management on significant operational or strategic developments between meetings, and, from time to time, engaging with shareholders.
Management Meetings and Site Visits
We encourage our directors to meet with senior managers throughout the enterprise and attend management’s strategic planning sessions. When considering businesses to visit, priority goes to those businesses identified as strategically important as well as those that were recently acquired. From time to time, the Board makes on-site visits to our businesses to tour the manufacturing facilities and meet face-to-face with company management and employees. These visits serve as an important tool in the Board’s succession planning process for our senior leadership team and enable a deeper understanding of our businesses and our culture.
Director Orientation and Education
All new directors participate in our director orientation program. New directors meet with senior corporate leaders to review and discuss our businesses, operations, strategy, end markets, governance, internal controls, and culture. We believe that our on-boarding approach, coupled with participation in regular Board and committee meetings, as well as additional exposure to our business through participation in management meetings and site visits, whether virtually or in-person, provides new directors a strong foundation in our businesses and accelerates their effectiveness to fully engage in Board deliberations.
Our Board also encourages directors to participate annually in continuing director education programs outside of the Boardroom, and we reimburse directors for their expenses associated with this participation.
Director Independence
Our Board has determined that each of the current members of the Board, except for Richard J. Tobin, who is our CEO, has no material relationship with Dover and satisfies all the criteria for being “independent” members of our Board. This includes the criteria established by the New York Stock Exchange (“NYSE”) listing standards, as well as our standards for classification as an independent director which are available on our website at www.dovercorporation.com. Our Board makes an annual determination of the independence of each nominee for director prior to his or her nomination for re-election. No director may be deemed independent unless the Board determines that he or she has no material relationship with Dover, directly or as an officer, shareholder or partner of an organization that has a material relationship with Dover.
Majority Standard for Election of Directors and Mandatory Resignation Policy
Under our by-laws and corporate governance guidelines, the voting standard in director elections is a majority of the votes cast. Under this majority of the votes cast standard, a director must receive more votes in favor of his or her election than votes against his or her election. Abstentions and broker non-votes do not count as votes cast with respect to a director’s election. In contested director elections (where there are more nominees than available seats on the board), the plurality standard will apply. Under the plurality standard, the nominees who receive the most “for” votes are elected to the Board until all seats are filled.
For an incumbent director to be nominated for re-election, he or she must submit an irrevocable resignation letter. The resignation will be contingent on the nominee not receiving a majority of the votes cast in an uncontested election and on the Board’s acceptance of the resignation. If an incumbent director fails to receive a majority of the votes cast in an uncontested election, the Governance and Nominating Committee will make a recommendation to our Board concerning whether to accept or reject the resignation or whether other action should be taken. Our Board will act on the resignation within 90 days following certification of the election results, taking into account the committee’s recommendation. The Board will publicly announce its decision and, if the resignation is rejected, the rationale for its decision.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 26
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Governance Guidelines and Code of Ethics
Our Board long ago adopted written corporate governance guidelines that set forth the responsibilities of our Board and the qualifications and independence of its members and the members of its standing committees. The Board reviews these guidelines at least annually, in light of evolving best practices, shareholder feedback and the evolution of our business. In 2020, the Board amended the guidelines to require that initial lists of potential director and external CEO candidates presented by third-party search firms include qualified candidates who reflect diverse backgrounds, including diversity of gender and race or ethnicity.
As noted above in the “Governance Highlights” chart and in the “Criteria for Director Nominees” section, enhancing the diversity of the Board will be an important objective in connection with future director appointments.
In addition to the corporate governance guidelines, our Board has a long-standing Code of Conduct setting forth standards applicable to all of our companies and their employees, a code of ethics for our CEO and senior financial officers, and charters for each of its standing committees. All of these documents (referred to collectively as “governance materials”) are available on our website at www.dovercorporation.com.
Procedures for Approval of Related Person Transactions
We generally do not engage in transactions in which our senior executive officers or directors, any of their immediate family members or any of our 5% shareholders have a material interest. Should a proposed transaction or series of similar transactions involve any such persons and an amount that exceeds $120,000, it would be subject to review and approval by the Governance and Nominating Committee in accordance with a written policy and the procedures adopted by our Board, which are available with the governance materials on our website.
Under the procedures, management determines whether a proposed transaction requires review under the policy and, if so, presents the transaction to the Governance and Nominating Committee. The Governance and Nominating Committee reviews the relevant facts and circumstances of the transaction and approves or rejects the transaction. If the proposed transaction is immaterial or it is impractical or undesirable to defer the proposed transaction until the next committee meeting, the Chair of the committee decides whether to (i) approve the transaction and report the transaction at the next meeting or (ii) call a special meeting of the committee to review and approve the transaction. Should the proposed transaction involve the CEO or enough members of the Governance and Nominating Committee to prevent a quorum, the disinterested members of the committee will review the transaction and make a recommendation to the Board, and the disinterested members of the Board will then approve or reject the transaction. No director may participate in the review of any transaction in which he or she is a related person.
Communication with Directors
The Audit Committee has established procedures for (i) the receipt, retention and treatment of complaints regarding accounting, internal accounting controls or auditing matters (“accounting matters”) and (ii) the confidential, anonymous submission by employees of concerns regarding questionable accounting matters. Such complaints or concerns may be submitted to Dover, care of our Corporate Secretary or through the communications coordinator, an external service provider, by mail, fax, telephone, or via the internet as published on our website. The communications coordinator forwards such communications to Dover without disclosing the identity of the sender if anonymity is requested.
Shareholders and other interested persons may also communicate with our Board and the non-management directors in any of these same manners. Such communications are forwarded to the Chair of the Governance and Nominating Committee.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 27
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Shareholder Engagement and History of Board Responsiveness
Shareholder Engagement
In 2022, we continued our focus on regularly engaging with our shareholders. We reached out to holders of approximately 63% of our shares outstanding, and engaged with governance professionals and/or portfolio managers at investors holding approximately 39% of our shares outstanding. Our shareholder engagement team consists of senior management and has also included our Chair from time to time. We also participate in various governance forums with our shareholders and regularly engage with shareholders through industry conferences and meetings.
We received feedback from investors on a range of topics, including corporate governance topics such as shareholder ratification of executive termination pay. We are pleased with the feedback we received with investors on the topics we discussed, and look forward to ongoing engagement with our shareholders in order to continue to incorporate their views into our Board’s decision-making process. We aim to have best-in-class governance and compensation structures at Dover.
KEY ITEMS OF DISCUSSION AND FEEDBACK | ||
Performance & Long-Term Strategy |
• We reviewed our portfolio of businesses, performance, strategic priorities, and focus on continuing to deliver long-term value to shareholders despite challenging market environments. | |
Capital Allocation |
• We discussed how our balance sheet strength and history of prudent capital allocation serve as differentiating factors that allow us to remain flexible. | |
Diversity & Inclusion |
• We discussed how we are taking a thoughtful approach to developing a center-led approach to human capital management and diversity and inclusion.
• Shareholders expressed appreciation for continued transparency on the sustainability portion of our website regarding workforce demographics (gender, ethnicity, age).
• We also discussed the progress we made regarding our diversity & inclusion goals, including successfully completing our first annual global engagement survey and expanding the breadth of our unconscious bias training for people leaders. | |
ESG |
• We discussed that, in 2022, we continued to execute on our three-year ESG strategy to expand our disclosures, metrics, goals and oversight, and continued to publish against key frameworks (SASB and GRI).
• We discussed that we continued to report progress against our science-based targets to reduce our GHG emissions, and our continuing to report progress against our goal of reducing TRIR by 40% by 2025 (from a 2019 baseline year). | |
Executive Compensation |
• We discussed our severance practices and the potential adoption of a cash severance policy.
• After enhancements to our compensation program in recent years, informed by extensive shareholder feedback, shareholders expressed continued support of our executive compensation program, which ensures continued alignment with our strategy and performance. In addition, they expressed support for continuing to include the effective oversight and management of ESG matters as a strategic objective for our CEO under the AIP. | |
Corporate Governance |
• Our shareholders continued to express their broad support for our governance practices and shareholder rights, including special meeting right, use of annual director elections, and independent Board leadership structure, and thoughtful and active refreshment process.
• Many of our shareholders expressed appreciation for the adoption by the Board in 2022 of an amendment to the Governance and Nominating Committee’s charter to provide for oversight of Dover’s practices on political contributions and lobbying expenses. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 28
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
History of Board Responsiveness
We are committed to being responsive to our shareholders as demonstrated by the number of changes we have made over the years based on their input. In direct response to shareholder feedback, over the past 9 years, Dover has adopted and amended our special meeting right, adopted proxy access, implemented meaningful changes to our executive compensation program, removed all our super-majority voting provisions in our charter, adopted a robust clawback policy, and enhanced our disclosures to investors. The table below highlights many of the changes to our governance structures and compensation program that have been implemented over the past several years informed by shareholder feedback. These changes specifically address shareholders’ areas of focus and input gathered through our extensive shareholder engagements and outreach efforts.
Year |
% of Outstanding Shares
|
Actions in Response to Shareholder Feedback | ||||||
|
![]() |
2023 | Ongoing |
✓ Currently engaging with shareholders on corporate governance, executive compensation and sustainability ahead of the 2023 Annual Meeting | ||||
2022 | 63% / 39% |
✓ Made several ESG accomplishments including: ✓ Completing one diversity & inclusion goal and staying on track to complete the other ✓ Continuing to disclose progress against GHG emissions goals and TRIR reduction goals ✓ Amending Governance and Nominating Committee’s charter to provide for oversight of Dover’s practices on political contributions and lobbying expenses | ||||||
2021 | 59% / 31% |
✓ Continued to maintain a refreshed and diverse board by appointing an additional female director ✓ Made several ESG accomplishments including: ✓ Announcing goals to reduce our GHG emissions by 2030 ✓ Undertaking a climate risk assessment aligned with the TCFD reporting framework ✓ Setting new diversity & inclusion goals ✓ Establishing a working group of operating companies with a goal of embedding sustainability considerations into product development | ||||||
2020 | Winter: 65% / 15%
Lead-up to 2020 AGM: 51% / 12%
Fall: 59% / 38% |
✓ Implemented for 2020 executive compensation program: ✓ Increased proportion of LTIP dedicated to performance shares and shifted from internal TSR to relative TSR as metric for performance shares ✓ Reduced maximum payout ceiling from 400% to 300% in LTIP ✓ Reduced ownership threshold required to call a special meeting of shareholders to 15% from 25% ✓ Adopted a diversity search policy for external director and CEO searches conducted by third-party search firms ✓ Made several ESG accomplishments including: ✓ A robust materiality assessment to help identify go-forward focus areas ✓ The launch of the sustainability portion of our website ✓ Publication of SASB and GRI indices ✓ Release of an “investor tear sheet” covering key ESG highlights ✓ Increased transparency into workforce demographics | ||||||
2019 | Lead-up to 2019 AGM: 63% / 37%
Fall: 63% / 41% |
✓ Achieved removal of all supermajority provisions through submission of management proposal and comprehensive retail investor campaign ✓ Enhanced disclosure regarding individual strategic objectives and financial metrics in AIP ✓ Adopted comprehensive clawback policy ✓ Incorporated ESG oversight into CEO’s individual strategic objectives in AIP | ||||||
2018 | 51% / 32% |
✓ Put forth management proposal to remove supermajority voting provisions alongside comprehensive campaign with retail investors to build support – did not pass | ||||||
2017 | 53% / 33% |
✓ Updated AIP to 60% financial metrics / 40% strategic objectives from 50% / 50% ✓ Put forth management proposal to remove supermajority voting provisions – did not pass | ||||||
|
2016 | 60% / 28% |
✓ Adoption of proxy access ✓ Put forth management proposal to provide shareholders with written consent right – did not pass | |||||
|
2015 | 39% / 24% |
✓ Launch of governance-focused shareholder engagement program | |||||
|
2014 |
- / - |
✓ Adoption of special meeting right |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 29
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Environmental, Social, and Governance Oversight (ESG)
Throughout our history, our commitment to corporate responsibility and sustainability has created significant value for our shareholders and stakeholders. Our vision for sustainability at Dover is “a sustainable innovation for every customer challenge.” This vision helps guide our efforts across our portfolio of operating companies and a team of over 25,000 employees. We remain focused on operating sustainably to help meet the goals of our customers, realize the full potential of our employees by fostering a culture that supports and values their efforts, and strengthen the communities in which we operate. For more information on our initiatives and accomplishments, please visit https://www.dovercorporation.com/sustainability/overview.
ESG Areas of Focus and Materiality Analysis
We pursue sustainability initiatives that support our employees, customers, and communities to ensure our businesses continue to create long-term value for our shareholders. Our eighteen ESG areas of focus — identified and prioritized in our materiality analysis conducted in 2020 – represent the ESG issues most important to our business and stakeholders and have guided our sustainability strategy during our inaugural three-ESG plan. Please see below for the specific areas of focus identified through the analysis. For each sustainability topic, we are applying our resources, expertise, and innovation to improve outcomes and drive results.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 30
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Governance Oversight of ESG
Our governance framework serves as a strong foundation to promote the long-term interests of our shareholders. Our Board oversees our long-term strategic development and enterprise risk, including ESG risks. The Board’s oversight spans a wide array of ESG issues, including those related to climate change, health and safety, diversity and inclusion, ethics and compliance, and long-term environmental protection. As part of its continued focus on sustainability, our Board incorporates ESG oversight into the CEO’s annual performance and compensation evaluation as one of the CEO’s strategic objectives. The Board also has established a comprehensive enterprise risk management process to identify and manage risks, including any risks related to environmental and social issues.
Additionally, our cross-functional Sustainability Steering Committee was established in 2020 to manage ESG issues, typically meets at least four times per year, and provides an update to the Board at least annually. In 2022, we formalized the organization and structure of the Sustainability Steering Committee in a committee charter. The committee is responsible for guiding our sustainability strategy, initiatives, target-setting, performance, and reporting.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 31
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Progress Toward Goals
We made progress on a number of fronts in line with our three-year ESG plan and are on track to meet each of our goals. These goals include our 2030 science-based targets to reduce both our operational and value chain greenhouse gas emissions as well as our goals to promote employee health and safety and diversity and inclusion. In 2022, we launched our first global employee engagement survey and have expanded the breadth of our unconscious bias training for people leaders. We continue to disclose progress against our greenhouse gas emissions and TRIR reduction goals. Also, as part of our efforts around increasing our focus on developing products that help our customers meet their sustainability goals, we have put in place working groups to develop and share best practices for embedding sustainability considerations into new product development.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 32
PROPOSAL 1 — ELECTION OF DIRECTORS
Directors’ Compensation
Our non-employee directors’ annual compensation is payable partly in cash and partly in common stock in an allocation our Board may adjust from time to time. If any director serves for less than a full calendar year, the compensation to be paid to that director for the year will be pro-rated as deemed appropriate by our Compensation Committee.
Our Board has adopted a policy that directors are expected to hold at any time a number of shares at least equal to the aggregate number of shares they received as the stock portion of their annual retainer during the past five years, net of an assumed 30% tax rate.
FOR 2022, NON-EMPLOYEE DIRECTOR COMPENSATION WAS AS FOLLOWS: |
Annual retainer of $285,000, payable $165,000 in common stock and $120,000 in cash |
Audit Committee Chair — additional annual cash retainer of $30,000 |
Compensation Committee Chair — additional annual cash retainer of $20,000 |
Governance and Nominating Committee Chair and Finance Committee Chair — additional annual cash retainer of $15,000 |
Board Chair — additional annual retainer of $170,000, payable $130,000 in cash and $40,000 in common stock |
Under our 2021 LTIP, each non-employee director can elect to defer the receipt of 0%, 50%, or 100% of the equity compensation payable in a year until termination of services as a non-employee director. Shares deferred are converted into deferred stock units representing the right to receive one share of our common stock for each unit held at the end of the deferral period. Dividend equivalents are credited on deferred stock units and will be distributed in cash at the time that shares are distributed in settlement of deferred stock units. Messrs. Johnston, Spiegel, Todd, and Wagner and Mses. Graham and DeHaas elected to defer receipt of their 2022 equity compensation and received deferred stock units.
The table below sets forth the compensation paid to our directors for services in 2022.
NAME |
FEES EARNED OR PAID IN CASH ($)(1) |
STOCK AWARDS ($)(2) |
TOTAL ($) |
|||||||||
DEBORAH L. DEHAAS |
|
120,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
285,048 |
| |||
H. JOHN GILBERTSON, JR |
|
120,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
285,048 |
| |||
KRISTIANE C. GRAHAM |
|
120,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
285,048 |
| |||
MICHAEL F. JOHNSTON |
|
250,000 |
|
|
204,995 |
|
|
454,995 |
| |||
MICHAEL MANLEY(3) |
|
— |
|
|
— |
|
|
— |
| |||
ERIC A. SPIEGEL |
|
135,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
300,048 |
| |||
STEPHEN M. TODD |
|
150,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
315,048 |
| |||
STEPHEN K. WAGNER |
|
135,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
300,048 |
| |||
KEITH E. WANDELL |
|
140,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
305,048 |
| |||
MARY A. WINSTON |
|
120,000 |
|
|
165,048 |
|
|
285,048 |
|
(1) | Amounts include the standard annual cash retainer, the Chair’s additional cash retainer, and the additional annual cash retainer for committee Chairs. |
(2) | On November 15, 2022, each of Messrs. Gilbertson and Wandell and Ms. Winston received 1,161 shares of common stock with an aggregate grant date fair market value of $165,048, Messrs. Spiegel, Todd and Wagner and Mses. Graham and DeHaas each received 1,161 deferred stock units with an aggregate grant date fair market value of $165,048, and Mr. Johnston received 1,442 deferred stock units with an aggregate grant date fair market value of $204,995, which included his additional compensation as Board Chair. |
(3) | Mr. Manley was first elected to the Board on February 9, 2023 and accordingly did not receive compensation in 2022. |
Our Compensation Committee reviews our non-employee director compensation policy biennially and proposes changes to the Board, as appropriate. The review is performed with the assistance of the Compensation Committee’s independent compensation consultant to assess the competitiveness of our non-employee director compensation policy based on benchmark information from peer companies and relevant compensation surveys.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 33
Proposal 2 — Ratification of Appointment of Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
The Audit Committee has appointed the independent registered public accounting firm of PwC to audit the annual accounts of Dover and its subsidiaries for 2023. PwC has audited the financial statements for the Company since 1995. Representatives of PwC are not expected to be present at the Annual Meeting.
Although shareholder ratification of PwC’s appointment is not required by Dover’s by-laws or otherwise, our Board is submitting the ratification of PwC’s appointment for the year 2023 to Dover’s shareholders. If the shareholders do not ratify the appointment of PwC, the Audit Committee will reconsider whether or not to retain PwC as Dover’s independent registered public accounting firm for the year 2023 but will not be obligated to terminate the appointment. Even if the shareholders ratify the appointment of PwC, the Audit Committee in its discretion may direct the appointment of a different independent registered public accounting firm at any time during the year if the Audit Committee determines that such a change would be in Dover’s interests.
THE BOARD RECOMMENDS A VOTE “FOR” RATIFICATION OF THE APPOINTMENT
OF PWC AS OUR INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM FOR THE YEAR 2023.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 34
PROPOSAL 2 — RATIFICATION OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
Audit Committee Report
The Audit Committee is composed of directors who, in the opinion of the Board, are independent and financially literate under NYSE rules and qualify as audit committee financial experts as defined by the SEC. Information concerning the credentials of the Audit Committee members can be found in the section of this proxy statement entitled “Proposal 1 — Election of Directors.”
The Audit Committee operates under a written charter adopted by the Board and available on Dover’s website. The Audit Committee assists the Board in overseeing the quality and integrity of Dover’s financial statements, compliance with legal and regulatory requirements, the qualifications, performance and independence of the independent auditors, and the performance of the internal audit function.
Among other things, the Audit Committee appoints the Company’s independent auditors and is directly involved in the selection of the lead audit engagement partner, discusses with the internal audit function and independent auditors the overall scope and plans for their respective audits, reviews the Company’s accounting policies and system of internal controls, reviews significant financial transactions, discusses with management and with the Board processes relating to risk management, pre-approves audit and permissible non-audit services provided by the independent auditors, and approves all fees paid to the independent auditors for such services.
For 2022, the Audit Committee engaged the independent registered public accounting firm PwC as Dover’s independent auditor. In selecting PwC, the Audit Committee considered, among other things: the experience and qualifications of the lead audit partner and other senior members of the PwC team; PwC’s historical performance on Dover’s audit and the quality of its communications with the Audit Committee; the results of the most recent internal quality control review or Public Company Accounting Oversight Board (“PCAOB”) inspection; PwC’s independence; its reputation for integrity and competence in the fields of accounting and auditing; the appropriateness of its fees; and its tenure as Dover’s independent auditors, including its understanding of the Company’s global businesses, accounting policies and practices, and internal control over financial reporting.
The Audit Committee discussed with PwC the overall scope and plans for the audit of Dover’s 2022 financial statements. The Audit Committee met with PwC, with and without management present, to discuss the results of PwC’s examination, their assessment of internal controls and the overall quality of financial reporting.
The Audit Committee reviewed and discussed, with both the management of Dover and PwC, Dover’s 2022 audited financial statements, including a discussion of critical accounting policies, the quality, not just the acceptability, of the accounting principles followed, the reasonableness of significant judgments reflected in such financial statements and the clarity of disclosures in the financial statements. The Audit Committee met a total of eight times in 2022 and 2023 to discuss 2022 quarterly and full-year financial results and related disclosures.
The Audit Committee has received the written disclosures and the Rule 3526 letter from PwC required by the applicable requirements of PCAOB regarding the independent auditor’s communications with the Audit Committee concerning independence, and discussed with PwC its independence, including the impact of any relationships or permitted non-auditing services on PwC’s independence. The Audit Committee also discussed with PwC the matters required to be discussed under PCAOB Auditing Standard No. 1301. The Audit Committee has also received written materials addressing PwC’s internal control procedures and other matters required by NYSE listing standards.
Based upon the review and discussions referred to above, the Audit Committee recommended that the audited financial statements for the year ended December 31, 2022 be included in Dover’s Annual Report on Form 10-K.
Audit Committee:
Stephen M. Todd (Chair) Deborah L. DeHaas H. John Gilbertson, Jr. Michael Manley Eric A. Spiegel Stephen K. Wagner
This report does not constitute “soliciting material” and shall not be deemed filed or incorporated by reference into any filing under the Securities Act of 1933 or under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, except to the extent we specifically incorporate this report by reference, and shall not otherwise be deemed filed under such Acts.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 35
PROPOSAL 2 — RATIFICATION OF APPOINTMENT OF INDEPENDENT REGISTERED PUBLIC ACCOUNTING FIRM
Fees Paid to Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
Fees paid to, or accrued for, PwC for services to us and our subsidiaries for 2022 and 2021 (including reimbursable expenses) were as follows:
2022 |
2021 |
|||||||
AUDIT FEES |
$ |
6,367,600 |
$ |
7,487,600 |
||||
AUDIT-RELATED FEES |
$ |
2,533 |
$ |
55,870 |
||||
TAX FEES |
$ |
39,078 |
$ |
182,323 |
||||
ALL OTHER FEES |
$ |
5,400 |
$ |
900 |
||||
|
|
|
|
|||||
TOTAL |
$ |
6,414,611 |
$ |
7,726,693 |
Audit Fees. Audit fees include fees for audit or review services in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards of our consolidated financial statements (including internal control over financial reporting), statutory and subsidiary audits and review of documents filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (“SEC”).
Audit-Related Fees. Audit-related fees include fees for assurance and related services that are reasonably related to the audit of our financial statements, including system implementation assessments.
Tax Fees. Tax fees include fees for services that are performed by professional tax staff other than in connection with the audit. These services include tax compliance, consulting and advisory services.
All Other Fees. Other fees include fees for non-audit services not listed above that do not impair the independence of the auditor and are not prohibited by the SEC or PCAOB.
Pre-Approval of Services Provided by Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm
Consistent with its charter and applicable SEC rules, our Audit Committee pre-approves all audit and permissible non-audit services provided by PwC to us and our subsidiaries. With respect to certain services which PwC has traditionally provided, the Audit Committee has adopted specific pre-approval policies and procedures. In developing these policies and procedures, the Audit Committee considered the need to ensure the independence of PwC while recognizing that, in certain situations, PwC may possess the expertise and be in the best position to advise us and our subsidiaries on issues and matters other than accounting and auditing.
The policies and procedures adopted by the Audit Committee allow the pre-approval by the Audit Committee of permissible audit-related services, non-audit-related services and tax services. Under the policies and procedures, pre-approval is generally provided for up to one year and any general pre-approval is detailed as to the particular services or category of services and is subject to a specific budget for each of them. The policies and procedures require that any other services be expressly and separately approved by the Audit Committee prior to such services being performed by the independent auditors. In addition, pre-approved services which are expected to exceed the budgeted amount included in a general pre-approval require separate, specific pre-approval. For each proposed service, the independent auditors and management are required to provide detailed information to the Audit Committee at the time of approval. The Audit Committee considers whether each pre-approved service is consistent with the SEC’s rules and regulations on auditor independence.
All audit-related and non-audit-related services of PwC during 2022 listed above under “Fees Paid to Independent Registered Public Accounting Firm” were pre-approved specifically or pursuant to the procedures outlined above. With respect to any tax services provided by PwC, PwC provided to the Audit Committee the communications required under PCAOB Rule 3524.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 36
Compensation Discussion and Analysis
This Compensation Discussion and Analysis (“CD&A”) describes our compensation program and how it operates for our NEOs. Our NEOs for 2022 were:
NAMED EXECUTIVE OFFICERS | ||
RICHARD J. TOBIN |
President & CEO | |
BRAD M. CEREPAK |
Senior Vice President & CFO | |
GIRISH JUNEJA |
Senior Vice President & Chief Digital Officer | |
IVONNE M. CABRERA |
Senior Vice President & General Counsel | |
KIMBERLY K. BORS |
Senior Vice President & Chief Human Resources Officer |
Executive Summary
Our compensation program is based on a pay-for-performance philosophy and is designed to incentivize executives to achieve financial and strategic goals that are aligned with the Company’s long-term business strategy and the creation of sustained, long-term value for our shareholders.
2022 Performance & Results
In 2022, despite an operating environment characterized by input shortages, inflationary cost pressures and foreign currency translation headwinds, we delivered strong financial results, made advancements in organic investments and productivity initiatives, and opportunistically stepped-up the return of capital to our shareholders, in keeping with our strategic priorities.
✓ | Generated revenue of $8.5 billion, up 8% (+9% organic) compared to the prior year. |
✓ | Delivered GAAP earnings per share of $7.42, down 4% compared to the prior year, and adjusted earnings per share of $8.45, up 11% compared to the prior year. |
✓ | Completed five bolt-on acquisitions for an aggregate consideration of $325.0 million, net of cash acquired and including contingent consideration, which complement and expand upon our existing operations. |
✓ | Made $221.0 million in capital expenditures in 2022, representing a recent record-high 2.6% of revenue, in line with our plan to support growth capacity, digitization, innovation, and productivity. |
✓ | Generated cash flow provided by operating activities of $805.7 million, and free cash flow of $584.8 million, representing 6.9% of revenue. |
✓ | Continued to evolve our operating model to include center-led value capture from digital opportunities, and continued to invest in growth and productivity initiatives, including automation, capacity expansion, and the implementation of common corporate systems and measurement tools. |
✓ | Completed $585 million in share repurchases, including a $500 million accelerated share repurchase program. |
✓ | Increased our quarterly dividend, marking our 67th consecutive year of dividend increases. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 37
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Financial Performance Summary
(1) | Definitions and reconciliations of non-GAAP measures are included at the end of this proxy statement. |
2022 Pay Decisions Align with Dover’s Performance
Our compensation program structure is designed to align pay outcomes with our shareholders’ experience by emphasizing variable, at-risk pay for our management team, including the NEOs, through our AIP and long-term incentive program.
For 2022, our pay decisions and outcomes were consistent with our pay-for-performance philosophy. Our NEOs made significant progress against their pre-defined individual strategic objectives as evaluated by our Compensation Committee under our AIP. As a result of strong operational and strategic achievements, 2022 annual bonus payouts were modestly above target but below last year. Consistent with our value creation over the three-year performance period of 2020-2022, the performance shares for that period, which vested at the end of 2022 and were based on relative TSR to the companies in the S&P 500 Industrials index, had a payout percentage of 71.4% for our NEOs.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 38
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Say on Pay Vote Results and Shareholder Engagement
94% Say on Pay support | 63% Shares Outstanding Contacted | 39% Shares Engaged |
Our Board has a strong history of engaging with shareholders and soliciting feedback on a range of topics, including our executive compensation program. Historically, our program has received strong shareholder support as expressed during our one-on-one engagement discussions with shareholders and through our Say on Pay vote levels.
At our 2022 annual meeting, approximately 94% of the voting shareholders approved the compensation of the NEOs. At our 2021 annual meeting, over approximately 93% of the voting shareholders approved the compensation of the NEOs. In 2022, we continued our shareholder engagement program. We reached out to holders of approximately 63% of our outstanding shares and engaged with governance professionals and/or portfolio managers of investors holding approximately 39% of our outstanding shares. In addition to the governance topics detailed earlier in this proxy statement, we had thoughtful discussions with our shareholders regarding our compensation program. Shareholders told us they believe our pay practices are aligned with our pay-for-performance philosophy. The Compensation Committee will continue to consider feedback from shareholders, as well as the results from future shareholder advisory votes, in its ongoing evaluation of executive compensation programs and practices at Dover.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 39
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Dover’s Alignment with Leading Compensation Governance Practices
WHAT WE DO | ||
✓ The majority of target NEO pay opportunity is performance based (75% for the CEO; 63% for the other NEOs)
✓ A significant portion of target NEO pay opportunity is tied to Dover stock performance (75% for the CEO; 52% for the other NEOs)
✓ Robust engagement with shareholders to seek feedback on executive compensation programs
✓ Compensation program includes ESG objectives
✓ All long-term incentives are paid in stock, not cash
✓ Executives must hold significant amounts of Dover stock: five-times salary for the CEO, three-times for other NEOs
✓ All long-term incentives are earned or vest over three years
✓ Change in control provisions require double trigger
✓ Comprehensive clawback policy
✓ Executives participate in benefit and employee programs on the same basis as other Dover employees
✓ Our Compensation Committee retains its own independent consultant
✓ Annual compensation risk assessment
|
WHAT WE DON’T DO | ||
✗ No tax gross ups
✗ No repricing, reloads, or exchanges of stock-settled stock appreciation rights (“SSARs”)
✗ No SSARs granted below fair market value
✗ No hedging or pledging of Dover securities by executives, including margin loans
✗ No dividends are paid on performance shares or restricted stock units (“RSUs”) during the earning or vesting period. Dividend equivalents are accrued on RSUs, but are only paid if the RSUs vest
✗ No special executive retirement arrangements
✗ No NEO cash severance over 2.99x the sum of base salary and target bonus without shareholder approval
✗ No substantial executive perquisites, nor do we own or operate any corporate aircraft
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 40
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Compensation Principles
Guiding Principles for Dover’s Executive Compensation Program
Based on these principles, these were the key elements of our executive compensation program in 2022:
✓ | Financial metrics that are clearly linked to the creation of shareholder value: adjusted earnings and three-year relative TSR. |
✓ | A focus on our business strategy to ensure our long-term compensation program aligns the interests of our executives with those of our shareholders by placing an emphasis on performance-based stock compensation. |
✓ | An annual review by our Compensation Committee of executive compensation levels and the components of our program. |
✓ | A reference to the median of our peer group for total direct compensation, with consideration for internal pay equity, sustained performance, specific responsibilities, and experience with comparable market talent. |
✓ | Total compensation opportunities designed so that the large majority of compensation is variable and at-risk based on financial, strategic, operational, and share price performance. |
✓ | An annual cash bonus plan (the AIP) designed to reward annual financial performance and the attainment of well-defined strategic objectives that the Board believes will assure the long-term success of Dover. |
✓ | Executive benefits and programs that are consistent with those offered to other employees. We provide substantially no executive perquisites, nor do we own or operate any corporate aircraft. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 41
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Compensation Process
Setting Executive Compensation — Roles
The process for determining our executive compensation program structure and payouts involves the dedicated participation of our Compensation Committee, the independent directors of the Board, the CEO, and our Compensation Committee’s independent consultant. The roles of each in making compensation decisions are:
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 42
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Setting Executive Compensation – Timeline
The process for making executive compensation decisions for 2022 began with goal setting at the beginning of the year and concluded with the actual compensation payout decisions in early 2023. As described below, this year-long process integrates key factors, such as Dover’s business strategy, our annual budget, and market compensation data.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 43
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Executive Compensation Program Peer Group
For assessing executive pay programs and levels, the Compensation Committee selected a group of companies that are similar to Dover in terms of end markets, complexity, revenues and market capitalization. In 2022, with the help of its independent consultant, the Compensation Committee approved changes to the existing peer group for the year 2023. Colfax Corporation was removed from the peer group following the spin-off of their fabrication technology business and Ametek, Inc. was added to the peer group.
FINANCIAL CONSIDERATIONS (IN USD MILLIONS) |
QUALITATIVE CONSIDERATIONS | |||||||||||||||
COMPANY |
2022 REVENUE |
2022 MARKET CAP(1) |
INDUSTRY |
>20% GLOBAL REVENUES |
DOVER-LIKE STRUCTURE |
SAME ANALYST COVERAGE(2) | ||||||||||
AMETEK, INC. |
$ | 6,151 | $ | 32,087 | Electrical Equipment |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
CARLISLE COMPANIES |
$ | 6,592 | $ | 12,150 | Industrial Conglomerates |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
CORNING INCORPORATED |
$ | 14,189 | $ | 27,015 | Electrical Equipment |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
EATON CORPORATION |
$ | 20,752 | $ | 62,419 | Electrical Equipment |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
EMERSON ELECTRIC CO. |
$ | 19,629 | $ | 56,810 | Electrical Equipment |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
FLOWSERVE CORPORATION
|
$
|
3,615
|
|
$
|
4,010
|
|
Machinery
|
✗
|
✗
| |||||||
FORTIVE CORPORATION |
$ | 5,826 | $ | 22,732 | Industrial Machinery |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
ILLINOIS TOOL WORKS INC.
|
$
|
15,932
|
|
$
|
67,673
|
|
Machinery
|
✗
|
✗
|
✗
| ||||||
INGERSOLL-RAND PLC
|
$
|
5,916
|
|
$
|
21,157
|
|
Machinery
|
✗
|
✗
|
✗
| ||||||
PARKER-HANNIFIN CORPORATION
|
$
|
15,862
|
|
$
|
37,366
|
|
Machinery
|
✗
|
✗
| |||||||
ROCKWELL AUTOMATION INC. |
$ | 7,760 | $ | 29,555 | Electrical Equipment |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
ROPER TECHNOLOGIES, INC. |
$ | 5,372 | $ | 45,824 | Industrial Conglomerates |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
SNAP-ON INCORPORATED |
$ | 4,843 | $ | 12,145 | Industrial Machinery |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
STANLEY BLACK & DECKER, INC. |
$ | 16,947 | $ | 11,113 | Industrial Machinery |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
TEXTRON INC. |
$ | 12,869 | $ | 14,781 | Aerospace & Defense |
✗ | ✗ | ✗ | ||||||||
XYLEM, INC. |
$ | 5,522 | $ | 19,927 | Industrial Machinery |
✗ | ✗ | |||||||||
75TH PERCENTILE |
$ | 15,879 | $ | 39,481 |
|
|||||||||||
MEDIAN |
$ | 7,176 | $ | 24,874 |
|
|||||||||||
25TH PERCENTILE |
$ | 5,750 | $ | 14,123 |
|
|||||||||||
DOVER |
$ | 8,508 | $ | 19,005 |
|
(1) | As of 12/31/2022. |
(2) | “Same analyst coverage” means company is covered by at least five of the analysts that cover Dover. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 44
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Role of Internal Equity in Setting Executive Compensation
Management and our Compensation Committee consider both market benchmarks (i.e., external competitiveness), as well as the impact each executive role has relative to internal peers (i.e., internal equity), in establishing the executive pay structures used to govern pay.
Retention and Independence of Compensation Consultant
Our Compensation Committee has the authority and discretion to retain external compensation consultants as it deems appropriate. Our Compensation Committee has adopted a policy to ensure the continuing independence and accountability to the committee of any advisor hired to assist the committee in the discharge of its duties. The policy formalizes the independent relationship between the Compensation Committee’s advisor and Dover, while permitting management limited ability to access the advisor’s knowledge of Dover for compensation matters. Under the policy, our Compensation Committee will annually review and pre-approve the services that may be provided to management by the independent advisor without further Compensation Committee approval. Compensation Committee approval is required prior to Dover retaining the independent advisor for any executive compensation services or other consulting services or products above an aggregate annual limit of $50,000.
Since September 2020, our Compensation Committee has retained Meridian Compensation Partners, LLC (“Meridian”) to serve as its independent compensation consultant. Meridian does no other work for and has no other relationships with Dover. Meridian is focused on executive compensation and does not have departments, groups, or affiliates that provide services other than those related to executive compensation and benefits.
Our Compensation Committee looks to its consultant to periodically review and advise regarding the adequacy and appropriateness of our overall executive compensation plans, programs, and practices and, from time to time, to answer specific questions raised by our Compensation Committee or management. Compensation decisions are made by, and are the responsibility of, our Compensation Committee and our Board, and may reflect factors and considerations other than the information and recommendations provided by our Compensation Committee’s consultant.
To ensure independence of the compensation consultant, the consultant reports directly to the Chair of our Compensation Committee and works specifically for the Compensation Committee solely on compensation and benefits.
Meridian did not engage in any projects for management in 2022. Our Compensation Committee has assessed the independence of Meridian and concluded that its work for the Compensation Committee does not raise any conflict of interest.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 45
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Elements of Executive Compensation
Variable, Performance-Based Compensation Program Structure Drives Pay-For-Performance Alignment
The pay packages of Dover executives consist predominantly of incentive-based pay, both annual and long-term. Each of the compensation components has a specific role in the overall design of our executive pay program. While the components are designed to be mutually reinforcing, care is taken to minimize overlap between them. The following table provides an overview of the 2022 compensation program structure.
Component |
Pay Element | 2022 Metrics & Weighting | Objectives | |||
Base Salary
|
Cash
|
◾ n/a
|
◾ Attract and retain qualified executives
◾ Benchmarked to peer group median while also considering additional factors such as experience and performance in role
| |||
Annual Incentive Plan (AIP) |
Cash |
◾ 60% Financial Results:
○ Adj. Earnings (100%)
◾ 40% Individual Strategic
○ ESG oversight included in CEO and select NEO individual strategic objectives
|
◾ Intended to drive profitability, growth, and progress against strategy
◾ Individual objectives are focused on a limited and measurable set of goals to benefit shareholders over the long-term
◾ Including ESG oversight in objectives establishes clear tone at the top regarding the importance of ESG
| |||
Long-Term Incentive Plan |
Performance Shares |
◾ 40% LTIP weighting
◾ Performance Criteria: 3-Year relative TSR with the S&P 500 Industrials index companies as the comparator group
|
◾ Focus executives on shareholder value creation
◾ Relative TSR closely aligns our executive-level measurement system with the experience of shareholders
| |||
SSARs |
◾ 40% LTIP Weighting
◾ Performance Criteria: Dover stock price, exercisable three years after grant date and remain exercisable for another seven years (subject to 10-year stock price movement)
|
◾ Focus executives on share price appreciation
◾ SSARs are an important component of our program, reflecting input from investors, many of whom acknowledge the role SSARs play in emphasizing growth and go-forward value creation
| ||||
RSUs |
◾ 20% LTIP weighting
◾ Performance Criteria: Dover stock price; awards vest ratably over three years
|
◾ Retention, ownership, and full alignment with the shareholder experience | ||||
Benefits
|
Consistent with other similarly situated employees
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 46
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
2022 Target Pay Mix
For 2022, the vast majority of the CEO’s and other NEOs’ target pay mix was composed of “at risk” incentive-based pay as shown in the chart below. Additionally, the target pay mix was heavily weighted toward long-term performance and tied to share performance, with the annual incentives focused on key short-term drivers and progress on strategy.
Annual Incentive Plan Compensation
An annual bonus may be earned each year based on an NEO’s performance against objectives tied to our financial performance as well as individual strategic goals. Each NEO’s bonus target amount is determined in reference to market benchmarking and according to the scope and complexity of the NEO’s functional responsibilities, overall impact on our results, strategic leadership, and managerial responsibility. We believe that balancing the measurement of performance for the annual bonus between financial and strategic objectives is important in mitigating risk and executing on our long-term strategy for value creation.
Each executive officer is eligible for a bonus equal to his or her base salary multiplied by his or her target award percentage multiplied by the Overall Payout Factor (which is the sum of the Financial Objective Factor (weighted 60%) and the Strategic Objectives Factor (weighted 40%)).
2022 AIP Financial Objective Factor – Target
The Financial Objective Factor in the 2022 AIP was calculated based on Adjusted Earnings. In setting the financial objective, our Compensation Committee considered our annual budget, operational priorities, plans for capital allocation, historical performance, and external factors, among other items. The target performance level for the financial objective was established at the beginning of the fiscal year and provided for appropriate adjustments for acquisitions and dispositions occurring during the year. For this measure, our Compensation Committee established threshold, target, and maximum levels of performance, as well as a payout percentage curve that relates each level of performance to a payout percentage.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 47
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Threshold and maximum performance levels are set at 85% and 107%, respectively, of target. There is no payout on the Financial Objective Factor if performance is below the threshold. At threshold, the payout percentage curve begins at 50%. If performance is at the target level, the payout percentage is 100%. For performance at or above the maximum level of achievement, the payout percentage is capped at 200%.
2022 AIP Financial Objective Factor – Results
Following the end of 2022, we calculated the Financial Objective Factor as follows:
2022 AIP FINANCIAL OBJECTIVE RESULTS (in millions) | ||||||||||
|
TARGET PERFORMANCE LEVEL |
ACTUAL PERFORMANCE LEVEL |
PAYOUT% (BEFORE WEIGHTING) |
WEIGHTING OF MEASURE |
WEIGHTED PAYOUT% | |||||
Adjusted Earnings(1) |
$1,248 |
$1,213 |
90.7% |
60% |
54.4% | |||||
Financial Objective Factor |
54.4% |
(1) | Definitions and reconciliations of non-GAAP measures are included at the end of this proxy statement. |
2022 AIP Individual Strategic Objectives Factor
The Strategic Objectives Factor is based on the achievement of individual strategic objectives designed to create long-term value for our shareholders. The strategic objectives for the CEO were developed by our Compensation Committee at the beginning of the year, approved by our independent directors, and communicated to the CEO in February. The individual strategic objectives were based on specific strategic initiatives that the Board and management agreed were important to achieve in 2022. These objectives were cascaded to the CEO’s direct reports, as appropriate, based on their responsibilities or business portfolio. The Board monitored progress on the CEO’s strategic objectives and, following the end of the year, reviewed the CEO’s performance against these objectives when determining his annual bonus.
Following the end of 2022, our Compensation Committee determined for each NEO a Strategic Objectives Factor between 0% and 200%. Our Compensation Committee believes such judgment is an important risk-mitigating element to our compensation program and provides an opportunity to further align executive compensation with long-term value creation. To make this determination, our Compensation Committee took into account each executive’s execution against his or her personal strategic objectives for the year and the executive’s overall performance for the year.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 48
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Strategic Objectives Factor — CEO
The table below summarizes the individual strategic objectives, weightings, and results the Compensation Committee considered for our CEO in determining his Strategic Objectives Factor for 2022.
Strategic Objectives & Accomplishments – Richard J. Tobin (President & CEO) |
Company Goals (20%)
|
✓ Progressed on our productivity initiatives and on our margin expansion initiatives, principally enabled by advances in e-commerce adoption and back-office consolidation. ✓ Continued to build on our four enterprise capabilities. ✓ Helped deliver additional margin upside by capturing synergies from recent acquisitions.
|
Capital Markets and Shareholder Engagement (20%)
|
✓ Engaged with investors regarding our long-term strategy execution and value-creation priorities. ✓ Reached out to holders of approximately 63% of outstanding shares and engaged with investors holding approximately 39% of outstanding shares.
|
Portfolio Management (20%)
|
✓ Effectively deployed capital to increase the value of our portfolio, including through investments in organic growth and $325 million deployed toward acquisitions. ✓ Increased capital expenditures to a recent record of $221 million. ✓ Completed the integration of several recent acquisitions that provide exposure to high-growth technologies and markets.
|
Talent, Succession Planning & Workforce Diversity (20%)
|
✓ Completed several objectives in the multi-year strategy to help ensure that our culture continues to take an inclusive approach that values diversity. ✓ Helped lead the expansion of our unconscious bias training for people leaders. ✓ Completed talent and succession planning review.
|
ESG (20%)
|
✓ Implemented the final year of a multi-year ESG strategic plan by continuing to report progress toward public facing goals on ESG topics, including GHG emissions; we are on track to meet each of our goals. ✓ Completed our first annual global engagement survey. ✓ Developed and reviewed new three-year ESG plan with the Board.
|
Our Compensation Committee evaluated Mr. Tobin’s achievements against his strategic objectives and assigned him a Strategic Objectives Factor of 120%.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 49
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Strategic Objectives Factor — Other NEOs
The following table summarizes the individual strategic objectives and results the Compensation Committee considered for our other NEOs in determining their respective Strategic Objectives Factors for 2022.
Brad M. Cerepak (Senior Vice President & CFO) Strategic Objectives & Accomplishments
|
Corporate Strategy (25%) ✓ Evaluated options for capital deployment. ✓ Helped Dover opportunistically step-up the return of capital through $585 million in share repurchases and to raise our dividend for the 67th consecutive year. ✓ Supported the alignment of key metrics and market positions to drive shareholder communications.
Capital Structure Analysis (25%) ✓ Assisted in the preparation of our three-year capital structure plan.
Finance Transformation and Control Environment (25%) ✓ Continued our commitment to optimize the structure of our finance team and improve process efficiency of shared services. ✓ Enhanced our internal controls environment.
Audit Plan Initiatives (25%) ✓ Conducted assessment of internal audit program and improved the efficiency of audits.
|
Assigned Strategic Objectives Factor of 120%
|
Girish Juneja (Senior Vice President & Chief Digital Officer) Strategic Objectives & Accomplishments
|
Digital Strategy (25%) ✓ Supported our strategic initiatives and priorities by assessing the digital capabilities of acquisition targets and driving adoption of shared services and common practices. ✓ Helped progress our information technology centralization initiatives.
Digital Customer Experience (25%) ✓ Continued support in building common platforms to enhance the customer experience and deliver efficiencies by enabling automated transactions.
Data Security (25%) ✓ Supported our enterprise-wide strategy for data security.
Product Development (25%) ✓ Helped expand our connected software and machine learning augmented solutions, which were built to integrate and work with our equipment and component offerings.
|
Assigned Strategic Objectives Factor of 120%
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 50
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Ivonne M. Cabrera (Senior Vice President, General Counsel & Secretary) Strategic Objectives & Accomplishments
|
ESG (25%) ✓ Continued effective leadership of our Sustainability Steering Committee and key roles in driving initiatives and communications aligned with completing our initial three-year ESG plan and developing a new three-year plan.
Commercial Contracts (25%) ✓ Supported the standardization of contract practices and tools across the enterprise.
Legal Spend Optimization (25%) ✓ Expanded the use of technology to collect and leverage data to drive cost optimization initiatives and support strategic priorities.
Intellectual Property (25%) ✓ Continued to engage with operating companies to align intellectual property activities with strategic priorities and to develop, product and maintain their intellectual property rights.
|
Assigned Strategic Objectives Factor of 120%
|
Kimberly K. Bors (Senior Vice President & Chief Human Resources Officer) Strategic Objectives & Accomplishments
|
Enterprise Talent Management (25%) ✓ Continued to enhance our talent management processes, capabilities and succession depth across the enterprise.
Strategic HR Project Initiatives (25%) ✓ Established strategy to harmonize and streamline aspects of global benefits programs. ✓ Supported the roll out of a global career architecture and compensation structure.
ESG/Diversity & Inclusion (25%) ✓ Completed our first annual global engagement survey. ✓ Helped implement Diversity & Inclusion roadmap initiatives, including through the expansion of our unconscious bias training for employees with direct reports.
Global HR Operating Model (25%) ✓ Helped implement the global operating model designed to expand shared services and centers of expertise and improve the operational effectiveness of the human resources function.
|
Assigned Strategic Objectives Factor of 120%
|
The Overall Payout Factors resulting from the above Financial Objective Factors and the Strategic Objectives Factors resulted in the payouts set forth in the 2022 Summary Compensation Table.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 51
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Long-Term Incentive Compensation
The following table summarizes the components of awards under our LTIP and the related performance criteria for awards granted in 2022. Note that all components are paid in stock rather than cash to encourage shareholder alignment through stock ownership.
Pay Element | 2022 Weighting & Performance Criteria | Objectives | ||
Performance Shares |
◾ 40% LTIP weighting
◾ Performance Criteria: 3-Year relative TSR with the S&P 500 Industrials index companies as the comparator group |
◾ Focus executives on shareholder value creation | ||
Stock Settled Stock Appreciation Rights |
◾ 40% LTIP weighting ◾ Performance Criteria: Dover stock price, exercisable three years after grant date and remain exercisable for seven years (subject to 10-year stock price movement) |
◾ Focus executives on share price appreciation | ||
Restricted Stock Units |
◾ 20% LTIP weighting ◾ Performance Criteria: Dover stock price; awards vest ratably over three years |
◾ Retention and full alignment with the shareholder experience |
Performance Shares – Relative TSR Metric
In February 2022, the Compensation Committee approved the grant of performance shares to each of our NEOs. Performance shares are earned based on our relative TSR performance against the S&P 500 Industrials index companies measured over the three-year performance period ending December 31, 2024. The relative TSR metric provides shareholders with a transparent and simple measure to gauge our performance against companies in our industry, and aligns the interests of our executives with our shareholders. The relative TSR targets for our performance shares are highly competitive. Awards are earned three years after the grant, provided relative TSR exceeds a threshold level with a maximum payout capped at 300% of target.
Payouts are made on a sliding scale using the following formula based on our relative TSR performance:
Performance share payouts will be capped at 100% if absolute TSR is negative over the performance period.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 52
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Performance Shares Vested in 2022
The performance shares vested in 2022 are based on the three-year performance period of 2020-2022, and the performance is measured on relative TSR as described above. Consistent with our value creation over the three-year performance period, the performance shares vested in 2022 had a payout percentage of 71.4% for our NEOs.
Target # of Shares
|
Actual Shares Awarded
|
|||||||||
Richard J. Tobin |
26,698 | 19,062 | ||||||||
Brad M. Cerepak |
6,674 | 4,765 | ||||||||
Girish Juneja |
1,669 | 1,192 | ||||||||
Ivonne M. Cabrera |
2,670 | 1,906 | ||||||||
Kimberly K. Bors |
1,669 | 1,192 |
Stock Settled Stock Appreciation Rights
Stock Settled Stock Appreciation Rights (SSARs) give our NEOs the ability to participate in the price appreciation of a set number of shares of Company stock. Once SSARs vest, an NEO may exercise them any time prior to the expiration date and the proceeds from the exercise are paid to the NEO in the form of shares of Dover common stock to encourage continued share ownership and shareholder alignment. SSARs vest and become exercisable 3 years after the grant date and remain exercisable for seven years, which means the awards are subject to 10-year stock price movement thus aligning executive interests with shareholder interests over the long term. Importantly, in light of our active acquisition program, SSARs’ forward-looking orientation is effective for incentivizing our newly-acquired companies and employees, who must create new value in order to realize gains. Furthermore, SSARs’ 10-year life cycle is essential to managing value creation with a business that has a portfolio of industrial companies whose economic cycles vary.
Restricted Stock Units
RSU grants attract and retain NEOs by providing them with some of the benefits associated with stock ownership during the vesting period. Executives do not actually own the shares underlying the units, nor do they enjoy the benefits of ownership such as dividends and voting, until the vesting conditions are satisfied. Once an NEO’s RSUs vest, the NEO receives a number of shares of Dover common stock equivalent in number to the vested units and receives a cash amount equal to any dividend equivalents that were accrued during the vesting period, net of withholding taxes.
Other Benefits
401(k), Pension Plan and Health & Wellness Plans
Our executive officers are able to participate in retirement and benefit plans generally available to our employees on the same terms as other employees. Dover and most of our businesses offer a 401(k) plan to substantially all U.S.-based employees and provide a Company matching contribution denominated as a percentage of the amount of salary deferred into the plan by a participant during the course of the year. Some of our U.S.-based employees also participate in a tax-qualified defined benefit pension plan. Effective December 31, 2013, we closed both our qualified and non-qualified defined benefit retirement plans to new employees. We intend to freeze any future benefit accruals in both plans effective December 31, 2023. All of our U.S.-based employees are offered a health and wellness plan (including health, term life and disability insurance). NEOs do not receive enhanced health and wellness benefits.
Non-Qualified Retirement Plans
We offer two non-qualified plans with participation generally limited to individuals whose annual salary and bonus earnings exceed the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) limits applicable to our qualified plans: our Pension Replacement Plan (“PRP”) and our deferred compensation plan. Participation in the deferred compensation plan is open to employees with an annual salary equal to or greater than $250,000 for 2022 deferral elections.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 53
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
After December 31, 2009, benefits under the PRP before offsets are determined using the benefit calculation and eligibility criteria as under the pension plan, except that IRS limits on compensation and benefits do not apply. Prior to December 31, 2009, the participants in the PRP accrued benefits greater than those offered in the pension plan. Effective January 1, 2010, we modified this plan so that executives subject to IRS compensation limits will accrue future benefits that are substantially the same as benefits under the pension plan. Individuals who participated in the PRP prior to January 1, 2010 will receive benefits calculated under the prior benefit formula through December 31, 2009 and benefits calculated under the lower PRP benefit formula on and after January 1, 2010. Amounts receivable by the executives under the PRP are reduced by any amounts receivable by them under the pension plan, any qualifying profit sharing plan, Company-paid portion of social security benefits, and the amounts of the Company match in the 401(k) plan.
Effective December 31, 2013, the PRP was closed to new employees. All eligible employees as of December 31, 2013 will continue to earn PRP benefits through December 31, 2023 as long as they remain employed by Dover and its affiliates. Effective December 31, 2023, Dover intends to eliminate any future benefit accruals consistent with the freezing of benefit accruals under the pension plan.
We offer a deferred compensation plan to allow participants to elect to defer their receipt of some or all of their salary, bonuses and any payout of a cash performance award. The plan permits executive officers to defer receipt of part of their compensation to later periods and facilitates tax planning for the participants. Effective January 1, 2022, the deferred compensation plan was amended to also provide for automatic Company contributions for participants who do not also participate in the PRP or have a present value benefit under the PRP of less than $100,000.
Executive Non-Change-in Control Severance Plan
All of our NEOs are eligible to participate in our severance plan. Under the plan, if we terminate an NEO’s employment without cause (as defined in the severance plan), the NEO will generally be entitled to receive twelve months of salary plus target annual cash bonus, outplacement services, and healthcare benefits continuation, and a prorated annual cash bonus and a prorated performance share award for time worked during the year. In addition, Mr. Tobin is entitled to receive certain severance payments and benefits under his employment agreement in the event his employment is terminated by Dover without cause or by him for good reason. See “Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change in Control.”
Senior Executive Change in Control Severance Plan
Our Senior Executive Change in Control Severance Plan (the “CIC Severance Plan”) establishes the severance benefits payable to eligible executives if they are involuntarily terminated following a change in control. All of our NEOs are eligible to participate in the CIC Severance Plan. An executive eligible to participate in the CIC Severance Plan as of the date of a change in control will be entitled to receive severance payments under the plan if, within 24 months after the change in control, either the executive’s employment is terminated by the Company without “cause” or he or she terminates employment for “good reason” (as such terms are defined in the plan). The severance payments and benefits will consist of: a lump sum payment equal to 2.0 times their annual salary and target bonus, a prorated annual cash bonus at target, full acceleration of all unvested SSARs and RSUs, performance share payout at target for all in-cycle awards, outplacement services, and a lump sum payment equal to the cost of Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) health care benefit continuation of the executive and covered family members for 24 months. See “Potential Payments Upon Termination or Change in Control.” No executive may receive severance benefits under more than one plan or arrangement. Dover does not provide tax gross-ups in the CIC Severance Plan.
Executive Cash Severance Policy
Following discussions with investors, on February 9, 2023, the Compensation Committee adopted a new executive officer cash severance policy that applies to any new employment agreement, severance agreement or separation agreement with any executive officer of the Company or any new severance plan or policy covering any executive officer of the Company. The policy provides that cash severance benefits under any such new arrangement will be limited to no more than 2.99 times the sum of the executive officer’s base salary plus target annual bonus, unless approved by shareholders. The Compensation Committee believes that this policy will serve the interests of shareholders while preserving the Company’s ability to remain competitive in the market for talent.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 54
COMPENSATION DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS
Other Elements of Compensation
Clawback Policy
In 2019, we adopted a formal clawback and recoupment policy applicable to our executive officers. If our Board determines, in its sole discretion acting in good faith, that any executive officer has engaged in fraud or intentional misconduct that caused or was a significant contributing factor to a material restatement of all or a portion of our consolidated financial statements, the Board may, to the extent permitted by law, and to the extent it determines that it is in Dover’s best interest, require reimbursement to Dover for, or reduce or cancel, any incentive compensation paid, granted or credited to such executive officer on or after November 7, 2019. We may effect any such recoupment by requiring the executive officer to pay Dover the relevant amount, by set-off, by reducing future compensation or by such other means or combination of means as the Board determines to be appropriate. The Company expects to update its clawback and recoupment policy as may be necessary to comply with the NYSE listing standards issued in connection with the SEC rules promulgated under the Dodd-Frank Act.
Apart from the clawback policy described above, our PRP includes clawback provisions for termination for cause and the severance plan and CIC Severance Plan provide for clawback of benefits for breaches of the plan.
Anti-hedging and Anti-pledging Policy
Our Securities Trading and Confidentiality Policy prohibits directors, executive officers and any employee who has previously received or receives any type of long-term incentive plan award, and certain persons and entities related to any such persons, from engaging in short-sales, transactions in derivative securities or any other form of hedging transaction designed to hedge or offset any decrease in the market value of Dover securities granted to or held by such persons. In addition, such persons may not hold Dover securities in a margin account or pledge securities as collateral for a loan or any other obligation.
Perquisites
We provide substantially no executive perquisites, other than the payment for executive physicals, nor does the Company own or operate any corporate aircraft. Management and our Compensation Committee believe that providing significant perquisites to executive officers would not be consistent with our overall compensation philosophy. As a result, we do not provide executive officers with perquisites such as social club memberships, company cars or car allowances, or financial counseling..
Shareholding Guidelines
We believe that our executives will most effectively pursue the long-term interests of our shareholders if they are shareholders themselves. As a result, share ownership guidelines are in place for all NEOs (subject to exceptions that may be granted by our Compensation Committee for significant personal events or retirement planning). Our CEO is required to hold shares equal in value to five-times salary and our other NEOs are required to hold shares equal in value to three-times salary. Our policy requires that NEOs hold/retain all equity grants until the share ownership guidelines are met. Based on current share ownership, all executives serving as NEOs are currently in compliance with the guidelines. Our Compensation Committee reserves the right to provide a portion of annual bonus in stock for any officer who fails to meet or make satisfactory progress toward satisfying the guidelines.
Risk Assessment
In 2022, Dover, with the assistance of Willis Towers Watson, updated the formal risk assessment that was conducted in 2020 for all our incentive compensation programs that have material impact on our financial statements. Willis Towers Watson inventoried incentive compensation programs at the corporate and operating company levels globally and conducted in-depth reviews of financially material plans, identified based on expected spend and income statement accounts tied to the program. The reviews focused on both the plan design features as well as internal risk mitigation controls in place. Based on this assessment, we have concluded that Dover’s compensation practices and policies do not create risks that are reasonably likely to have a material adverse effect on the Company.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 55
Compensation Committee Report
We reviewed and discussed with management the Compensation Discussion and Analysis for the year ended December 31, 2022.
Based on the review and discussions referred to above, we recommended to the Board of Directors that the Compensation Discussion and Analysis be included in this Proxy Statement and incorporated by reference in Dover’s Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022.
| ||||
Compensation Committee: |
Keith E. Wandell (Chair) Kristiane C. Graham Michael F. Johnston Mary A. Winston |
|||
This report does not constitute “soliciting material” and shall not be deemed filed or incorporated by reference into any filing under the Securities Act of 1933 or under the Securities Exchange Act of 1934, except to the extent the Company specifically incorporates this report by reference, and shall not otherwise be deemed filed under such Acts.
|
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 56
Executive Compensation Tables
Summary Compensation Table
The Summary Compensation Table and notes show all remuneration for 2022 provided to our NEOs, consisting of the following officers:
• | Our President & CEO; |
• | Our Senior Vice President & CFO; and |
• | Our three other most highly compensated executive officers as of the end of 2022. |
The determination of the most highly compensated executive officers is based on total compensation paid or accrued for 2022, excluding changes in the actuarial value of defined benefit plans and earnings on nonqualified deferred compensation balances.
Name and Principal Position | Year | Salary ($) |
Bonus ($)(1) |
Stock Awards ($)(2) |
Option Awards ($)(3) |
Non-Equity Incentive Plan Compensation ($)(4) |
Change in Pension Value and Nonqualified Deferred Compensation Earnings ($)(5) |
All Other Compensation ($)(6) |
Total ($) | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Richard J. Tobin President & Chief Executive Officer |
|
2022 |
|
|
1,261,250 |
|
|
1,951,101 |
|
|
6,213,263 |
|
|
4,201,489 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
516,149 |
|
|
14,143,252 |
| |||||||||
|
2021 |
|
|
1,235,000 |
|
|
2,964,000 |
|
|
5,808,134 |
|
|
3,580,475 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
498,251 |
|
|
14,085,860 |
| ||||||||||
|
2020 |
|
|
1,217,500 |
|
|
1,722,825 |
|
|
6,024,137 |
|
|
2,674,529 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
343,347 |
|
|
11,982,338 |
| ||||||||||
Brad M. Cerepak Senior Vice President & Chief Financial Officer |
|
2022 |
|
|
747,448 |
|
|
771,151 |
|
|
1,467,135 |
|
|
992,011 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
27,865 |
|
|
4,005,610 |
| |||||||||
|
2021 |
|
|
731,000 |
|
|
1,169,600 |
|
|
1,452,071 |
|
|
895,111 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
182,670 |
|
|
29,577 |
|
|
4,460,029 |
| ||||||||||
|
2020 |
|
|
718,000 |
|
|
679,830 |
|
|
1,505,922 |
|
|
668,627 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
649,315 |
|
|
35,329 |
|
|
4,257,023 |
| ||||||||||
Girish Juneja Senior Vice President & Chief Digital Officer |
|
2022 |
|
|
507,500 |
|
|
365,639 |
|
|
517,814 |
|
|
350,107 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
43,312 |
|
|
1,784,372 |
| |||||||||
|
2021 |
|
|
500,000 |
|
|
560,000 |
|
|
341,738 |
|
|
210,626 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
51,884 |
|
|
1,664,248 |
| ||||||||||
|
2020 |
|
|
491,404 |
|
|
325,500 |
|
|
376,533 |
|
|
167,157 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
38,967 |
|
|
1,399,561 |
| ||||||||||
Ivonne M. Cabrera Senior Vice President & General Counsel |
|
2022 |
|
|
589,400 |
|
|
460,275 |
|
|
690,353 |
|
|
466,851 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
17,484 |
|
|
2,224,363 |
| |||||||||
|
2021 |
|
|
560,000 |
|
|
627,200 |
|
|
546,632 |
|
|
336,979 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
17,922 |
|
|
2,088,733 |
| ||||||||||
|
2020 |
|
|
550,000 |
|
|
364,560 |
|
|
602,459 |
|
|
267,460 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
648,534 |
|
|
21,616 |
|
|
2,454,629 |
| ||||||||||
Kimberly K. Bors SVP & CHRO |
|
2022 |
|
|
460,125 |
|
|
332,302 |
|
|
365,896 |
|
|
247,414 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
37,616 |
|
|
1,443,353 |
| |||||||||
|
2021 |
|
|
450,000 |
|
|
504,000 |
|
|
362,136 |
|
|
223,247 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
0 |
|
|
43,615 |
|
|
1,582,998 |
|
(1) | Bonus amounts generally represent payments under our AIP for the year indicated, for which payments are made in the first quarter of the following year. The AIP constitutes a non-equity incentive plan under FASB ASC Topic 718. Although they are based on the satisfaction of pre-established performance targets, AIP amounts are reported in the bonus column rather than the non-equity incentive plan compensation column to make clear that they are annual bonus payments for the year indicated. |
(2) | The amounts generally represent (a) the aggregate grant date fair value of performance shares granted during the year indicated, and (b) the aggregate grant date fair value of restricted stock unit awards granted during the year, in each case, calculated in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718. The amounts set forth in the table do not correspond to the actual value that might be realized by the named executives. As market condition awards, the performance share awards granted in 2020 and after were valued using the Monte Carlo simulation model. For a discussion of the assumptions relating to calculation of the cost of equity awards, see Note 15 to the Notes to the Financial Statements contained in our Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2022. |
The grant date fair value for the 2020 performance share awards was $165.71, the grant date fair value for the 2021 performance share awards was $148.29 and the grant date fair value for the 2022 performance share awards was $196.40. The grant date fair value of 2022 RSU awards was $160.21. All RSU grants are eligible for dividend equivalent payments which are paid upon vesting. |
(3) | The amounts represent the aggregate grant date fair value of SSAR awards granted during the year indicated, calculated in accordance with FASB ASC Topic 718, and do not correspond to the actual value that may be realized by the named executives. The grant date fair value for the 2022 SSAR awards was calculated using a Black-Scholes value of $42.07 per SSAR. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 57
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION TABLES
(4) | See Note (1) for a discussion of annual bonuses under the AIP as non-equity incentive plan compensation. |
(5) | Amounts represent changes in present value of accumulated benefits under the pension plan and/or PRP during the year indicated. For more information, see “Executive Compensation Tables — Pension Benefits through 2022.” |
(6) | Amounts for 2022 represent: (i) 401(k) matching contributions of $10,675 for Mr. Cerepak and Ms. Cabrera and $13,725 for Messrs. Tobin and Juneja, and Ms. Bors, (ii) dividends received on RSUs in the amount of $371,593, $17,190, $4,020 and $6,809 and $1,957 for Messrs. Tobin, Cerepak, Juneja and Mses. Cabrera and Bors respectively, and (iii) for Messrs. Tobin and Juneja, and Ms. Bors, respectively, $130,831, $25,566 and $21,934 for the 4.5% non-elective contributions in the nonqualified deferred compensation plan, since they do not participate in the PRP. |
CEO Employment Agreement
In connection with the hiring of Mr. Tobin as our CEO, Mr. Tobin and Dover entered into a three-year employment agreement commencing May 1, 2018. In recognition of Mr. Tobin’s outstanding leadership and contributions to value creation, the agreement was renewed for a three-year period ending May 1, 2024. Under the terms of the agreement, Mr. Tobin is entitled to a minimum annual base salary of $1.2 million and a minimum target annual bonus equal to 125% of his base salary, and the receipt of an annual equity grant for each of Dover’s fiscal years ending during the term of the agreement with a grant date fair value of not less than $7 million. During the term of the agreement, Mr. Tobin will also be entitled to employee benefits on the same basis as those generally available to executive officers of Dover.
In connection with his hiring, Mr. Tobin received a one-time make-whole equity grant consisting of 75,971 performance shares, and 164,603 RSUs. Mr. Tobin also received a one-time make-whole cash payment of $1,000,000.
Mr. Tobin is entitled to receive certain severance payments and benefits in the event his employment is terminated by Dover without cause or by him for good reason. See “Potential Payments upon Termination or Change in Control.”
At the end of the term of the agreement, Mr. Tobin will continue to be employed by Dover as an at-will employee and participate in severance and other benefit plans on the same terms as other executives.
CEO Pay Ratio
We are providing the following information about the relationship of the annual total compensation of our Chief Executive Officer and our median employee. This ratio is a reasonable estimate calculated in a manner consistent with Item 402(u) of Regulation S-K.
For purposes of identifying our global median employee, in accordance with SEC rules we used the same global median employee for calculating the 2022 ratio as we did for calculating the 2021 ratio, as we believe that there has been no material change in our employee population or the employee compensation arrangements, or in the circumstances of the median employee.
For purposes of this analysis, our global headcount was 25,606 employees (13,329 U.S. and 12,227 non-U.S.) as of our December 31, 2022 determination date. Eleven countries were excluded (2.1% of the total workforce) under the permissible 5% exclusion, with employee counts as follows: Argentina (20), Colombia (4), Costa Rica (1), Dominican Republic (59), Indonesia (5), Malaysia (136), Mexico (111), Russian Federation (34), Taiwan (19), Thailand (130), and Turkey (13). After country exclusions, our total headcount was 25,074 employees (13,329 U.S. and 11,745 non-U.S.). As is permitted under the rules, to determine our median employee, we chose “base salary” as our consistently applied compensation measure. We estimated annual base salary for hourly workers employed for the entire year using their hourly rate and a reasonable estimate of hours worked for the year. For employees who commenced work during 2022, we annualized their annual base salary. We then produced a sample of employees who were paid within a 0.5% range of that median and selected an employee from within that group as our median employee. We determined that employee’s (Summary Compensation Table) total compensation was $51,237 for 2022.
We calculated 2022 annual total compensation for both our median employee and Mr. Tobin using the same methodology that we use to determine our named executive officers’ annual total compensation for the Summary Compensation Table. Mr. Tobin’s total compensation was $14,143,252 resulting in an estimated ratio of 276:1 for CEO pay to median worker pay.
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 58
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION TABLES
Grants of Plan-Based Awards in 2022
All awards listed in the table below have a grant date of February 11, 2022 for all executive officers. For a discussion of the awards, see “Compensation Discussion and Analysis – Elements of Executive Compensation.”
Name |
Type |
Estimated Future Payouts |
Estimated Future Payouts |
All Other Share of (#) |
All Other Securities |
Exercise Price of |
Grant Stock |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Threshold ($)(1) |
Target ($) |
Maximum ($) |
Threshold (#)(1) |
Target (#) |
Maximum (#) |
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Richard J. Tobin |
AIP (2) |
|
952,500 |
|
|
1,905,000 |
|
|
3,810,000 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SSAR (3) |
|
99,869 |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
4,201,489 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Performance |
|
22,471 |
|
|
67,413 |
|
|
4,413,304 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSU (5) |
|
11,235 |
|
|
1,799,959 |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brad M. Cerepak |
AIP (2) |
|
376,465 |
|
|
752,930 |
|
|
1,505,861 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SSAR (3) |
|
23,580 |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
992,011 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Performance |
|
5,306 |
|
|
15,918 |
|
|
1,042,098 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSU (5) |
|
2,653 |
|
|
425,037 |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Girish Juneja |
AIP (2) |
|
178,500 |
|
|
357,000 |
|
|
714,000 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SSAR (3) |
|
8,322 |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
350,107 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Performance |
|
1,873 |
|
|
5,619 |
|
|
367,857 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSU (5) |
|
936 |
|
|
149,957 |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Ivonne M. Cabrera |
AIP (2) |
|
224,700 |
|
|
449,400 |
|
|
898,801 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SSAR (3) |
|
11,097 |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
466,851 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Performance |
|
2,497 |
|
|
7,491 |
|
|
490,411 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSU (5) |
|
1,248 |
|
|
199,942 |
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Kimberly K. Bors |
AIP (2) |
|
162,225 |
|
|
324,450 |
|
|
648,900 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
SSAR (3) |
|
5,881 |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
247,414 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Performance |
|
1,323 |
|
|
3,969 |
|
|
259,837 |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
RSU (5) |
|
662 |
|
|
106,059 |
|
(1) | Represents the minimum amount payable for a certain level of performance. Under each of our plans, there is no guaranteed minimum payment. |
(2) | The amounts shown in this row reflect the potential payouts in February 2023 for 2022 under the AIP. The bonus amount actually paid in February 2023 is disclosed in the Summary Compensation Table in the column “Bonus” for 2022 for the executive officer. |
(3) | Represents an award of SSARs under the 2021 LTIP that will not be exercisable until February 11, 2025. The grant date fair value was calculated in accordance with FASB ASC 718, using a Black-Scholes value of $42.07 per SSAR. |
(4) | Represents an award of performance shares under the 2021 LTIP. The performance shares vest and become payable after the three-year performance period ending December 31, 2024 subject to the achievement of the applicable performance goal. The performance share awards are considered market condition awards per FASB ASC 718 and the grant date fair value for the awards was $196.40 per share, calculated using the Monte Carlo simulation model in accordance with FASB ASC 718. |
(5) | Represents an award of RSUs under the 2021 LTIP Plan made on February 11, 2022. The grant vests in three equal annual installments beginning on March 15, 2023. The grant date fair value for the awards were calculated in accordance with FASB ASC 718, using a value of $160.21 per share. |
DOVER CORPORATION – 2023 Proxy Statement 59
EXECUTIVE COMPENSATION TABLES
Outstanding Equity Awards at Fiscal Year-End 2022
Awards listed below with grant dates beginning in 2013 were made under the 2012 LTIP. All equity awards outstanding as of May 9, 2018 were adjusted as a result of the spin-off of Apergy Corporation (now known as ChampionX Corporation) to preserve the value of the awards in accordance with the Employee Matters Agreement, dated May 9, 2018, between Dover and Apergy.
Effective May 7, 2021, we adopted the 2021 LTIP. All grants of equity awards made on or after May 7, 2021 were made under the 2021 LTIP.
Option Awards | Stock Awards | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Name | Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options (#) Exercisable |
Number of Securities Underlying Unexercised Options (#) Unexercisable |
Option Exercise Prices ($) |
Option Expiration Date |
Number of Shares or Units of Stock That Have Not Vested (#) |
Market Value of Shares or Units of Stock That Have Not Vested ($) |
Equity Incentive Plan Awards: Number of Unearned Shares, Units or Other Rights That Have not Vested (#) |
Equity Incentive Plan Awards: Market or Payout Value of Unearned Shares, Units or Other Rights That Have not Vested ($) |
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Richard J. Tobin |
|
99,869 (1) |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
2/11/2032 |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
123,125 (2) |
|
|
122.73 |
|
|
2/12/2031 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
118,657 (3) |
|
|
119.86 |
|
|
2/14/2030 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
184,211 (4) |
|
|
91.20 |
|
|
2/15/2029 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
210,658 (5) |
|
|
79.75 |
|
|
5/23/2028 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
11,235 (12) |
|
|
1,521,331 (15) |
|
|
22,471 (16) |
|
|
3,042,798 (18) |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
9,235 (13) |
|
|
1,250,511 (15) |
|
|
27,703 (17) |
|
|
3,751,263 (18) |
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
4,450 (14) |
|
|
602,575 (15) |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Brad M. Cerepak |
|
23,580 (1) |
|
|
160.21 |
|
|
2/11/2032 |
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
30,781 (2) |
|
|
122.73 |
|
|
2/12/2031 |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
29,664 (3) |
|
|
119.86 |
|
|
2/14/2030 |
|